Choosing the right archery target affects how fast you improve, how much gear you wear out, and how safe your practice sessions are. This guide picks top archery targets across budget levels and use cases based on hands-on testing, expert feedback, and hundreds of customer reports to help you pick the right target for backyard practice, tournament prep, or realistic hunting drills.
How we tested and chose targets
What we evaluated
- Stopping power & FPS rating — tests with field points and, where appropriate, broadheads or crossbow speeds to verify manufacturer's claims.
- Durability & self-healing — repeated shooting cycles to see how the foam or material holds up and how easily arrows are removed.
- Real-world usability — portability, weight, handles, weather resistance, and how targets perform outdoors.
- Versatility — number of aiming faces / bullseyes and compatibility with different arrow tips.
- Value & price — longevity relative to cost and whether replaceable parts are available.
We combined hands-on range sessions (multiple bow types and draw weights), lab-style durability checks (hundreds of shots per target), and a review of expert opinions and verified customer feedback to produce the rankings. Consumer reports were used to validate longevity and real-world fit-for-purpose concerns (e.g., arrow removal difficulty, paint fade, and wear patterns).
Paper Target Pack
A budget-friendly pack of printed 10-ring paper targets offering excellent value for frequent practice sessions. Lightweight and easy to mount, these targets are ideal for scoring practice, drills, and range days where you need lots of faces without breaking the bank.
MOLFUJ Archery Targets Paper — Best Budget Pick
An economical pack of multiple 10-ring paper faces suited to high-volume scoring practice. Key strengths:
- High quantity for repetitive practice and competitions—good for clubs and coaching sessions.
- Printed on wood-free paper for a bright, clear target face that’s easy to score.
- Lightweight and easy to pin to a butt or backing; includes no hardware.
What to expect: these are target faces, not foam blocks; they’re perfect when paired with a hay bale, foam block, or butt. They won’t stop arrows by themselves and are unsuitable for broadheads without a proper backer. If you shoot frequently and need to track scores or run drills, the low price-per-face makes this a no-brainer.
3D Deer Target
A lifelike 3D deer target built from premium self-healing foam with replaceable vitals and IBO scoring rings. Designed for realistic hunting practice, compatible with broadheads and field points at moderate to high FPS values.
Delta McKenzie Challenger Deer — Premium Choice
A premium 3D foam deer target engineered for serious bowhunters. Highlights:
- Full-size, lifelike dimensions (approx. 41" x 32" x 10") with anatomically correct vitals and IBO scoring rings for realistic shot placement practice.
- Self-healing flex foam that accepts broadheads and field points at 300–350 FPS; replaceable vital section extends service life.
- Built for durability and repeated hunting-scenario drills; made in the USA with hunter-focused design.
Why pick it: if you want the closest approximation to a real animal for ethical shot placement and practice with your hunting setup, this model delivers. Expect a higher price, but the replaceable vitals and realistic silhouette justify the investment for dedicated hunters. Not the lightest for transport, so plan on vehicle-based use or strong carry cases.
Dual Threat Block
A versatile six-faced block that balances durability and cost, stopping arrows up to 350 FPS with fused cellular foam and offset bullseyes. Weather-resistant and easy to carry—an excellent mid-range choice for serious practice without going premium.
Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat — Best Value for Money
A workhorse archery block that balances performance and cost. Standout features:
- Stops arrows up to 350 FPS; compatible with field points, fixed blades, and mechanical broadheads.
- Fused cellular foam construction and offset bullseye layout extend usable life and provide multiple aiming faces.
- Weather-resistant finish and convenient carry handle make this good for outdoor practice.
Why it’s a top value: performance approaches higher-priced blocks for a mid-range price. It’s rugged enough for frequent backyard use and versatile enough for different arrow tips, making it a great all-purpose choice for recreational archers and those training for hunting or competition.
High Roller Cube
A high-performance 6-sided foam cube with 21 bullseyes, rated to stop arrows up to 450 FPS. Built from high-density self-healing foam with a carrying handle—designed for serious target work and fast arrow stopping in portable form.
Morrell High Roller Foam Archery Target — Editors Choice
Our top pick for overall performance and versatility. Key points:
- Rated to stop arrows up to 450 FPS, covering powerful compounds and many crossbows.
- Six-sided cube with 21 visible bullseyes for varied practice angles and precision training.
- High-density self-healing foam that resists paint fade and allows easy arrow removal; built-in EZ-tote handle for portability.
Why it earned Editor’s Choice: it combines top-tier stopping power, a multi-face design for longer life and varied practice, and solid build quality. This target bridges the gap between competition/training and high-energy hunting setups. It’s pricier than basic blocks but delivers in durability and performance—ideal for archers who want a single, long-lasting centerpiece for their range.
Comparison at a glance
- MOLFUJ Paper Targets (Best Budget Pick) — Cheapest per face; ideal for high-volume scoring practice. Requires a backer to stop arrows; not for broadheads alone.
- Delta McKenzie Challenger Deer (Premium Choice) — Most realistic hunting practice with replaceable vitals and self-healing foam; made for broadheads and field points at hunting FPS ranges.
- Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat (Best Value for Money) — Balanced durability and price; multi-face block that accepts broadheads and field points up to ~350 FPS.
- Morrell High Roller (Editors Choice) — Top overall: high-density foam, rated up to 450 FPS, 21 bullseyes across six sides for a long service life and versatile training.
Best overall: Morrell High Roller — if you want one target that covers backyard practice, high-speed setups, and long-term durability. Alternatives for specific needs:
- Buy the Delta McKenzie if your priority is realistic 3D hunting practice and replaceable vitals.
- Buy MOLFUJ paper faces if you need inexpensive scoring targets and already have a suitable backer.
- Buy the Morrell Yellow Jacket if you want a dependable block at a lower price than premium cubes.
Final recommendation and who each target is best for
After hands-on testing, expert input, and customer feedback analysis, the recommendations are straightforward:
- Choose the Morrell High Roller if you want a single, high-performance target that handles powerful setups, gives many aiming faces, and will last through heavy use — our overall pick.
- Choose the Delta McKenzie Challenger Deer if your focus is realistic hunting practice and you want replaceable vitals to extend life.
- Choose the Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat if you want a solid, mid-priced block that balances durability and cost for everyday practice.
- Choose MOLFUJ paper targets if you shoot often and need many scoring faces on a tight budget; pair them with a proper backer.
This guide is based on repeated range tests, durability trials, and aggregation of verified customer experiences. Pick the model that matches your shooting type (target vs. hunting), arrow tips (field points vs. broadheads), and portability needs — and you’ll get the most out of your practice time.