Choosing the right roofing nails matters: they affect installation speed, holding power, weather resistance and ultimately the longevity of a roof. This guide compares top roofing nail options available today — with emphasis on coil (collated) roofing nails for nail-gun users — based on hands-on testing, industry standards and customer feedback.
How we tested and chose
What we prioritized
- Compatibility with common roofing nail guns (angle, collation style, and diameter).
- Corrosion resistance (electro-galvanized vs. specialty coatings vs. stainless/aluminum).
- Holding power (smooth vs. ring shank or diamond point).
- Value per nail (count vs. price).
- Real-world performance (ease of feeding in nail gun, consistent penetration, and durability in roof exposures).
Sources & process
- Hands-on testing with 15° coil roofing nail guns, hammer-driven installations and simulated exposure tests.
- Cross-checks with product specification sheets, ASTM guidance where available, and professional roofer feedback.
- Analysis of hundreds of customer reviews to flag recurring failure modes (corrosion, misfeeds, bent nails).
How this influenced rankings
- Collated coil nails that feed reliably in nail guns and use electro-galvanized finishes scored highest for gun-first workflows.
- For hand-driven work we weighted shank design and head shape more heavily (ring shank and large-diameter heads for felt/underlayment).
Note: Collated (coil) roofing nail options on the market are limited; where coil options weren’t available we included high-quality non-collated roofing nails that are still top choices for manual roofing or small jobs.
BHTOP 600 Coil Nails
600-count, 1" x .120" 15° coil roofing nails designed for rapid pneumatic installation. Electro-galvanized finish resists corrosion; round head and smooth shank suit standard roofing felt and shingles. Affordable, compact roll format that feeds reliably in most 15° coil nailers.
BHTOP 600 Count Coil Roofing Nails — Best Budget Pick
These 15° coil roofing nails (1" x .120") are an economical entry to nail-gun roofing. They come in five rolls of 120 nails (600 total) and are electro-galvanized for basic corrosion resistance. In testing they fed cleanly through common 15° coil roofing nailers and produced consistent seating depth on asphalt shingles and underlayment.
Standout features:
- 15° coil format that fits the majority of roofing nail guns.
- Electro-galvanized finish for basic rust protection.
- Smooth shank and round head suitable for shingles and felt.
Why buy: If you run a smaller roofing nailer and need a low-cost coil that feeds reliably for roof repairs and small roof sections, this is a practical pick. Limitations: electro-galvanized steel is fine for standard exposure but is not the best choice for highly corrosive environments or contact with treated lumber.
1080 Coil Roofing Nails
1080-count, 1" x .120" 15° coil nails for high-volume roofing work. Wire-weld collated and electro-galvanized for improved corrosion resistance. Larger pack and consistent feed make these ideal for professional crews or frequent roof projects, lowering per-nail cost significantly.
1080 Count Coil Roofing Nails — Editors' Choice
This larger 1080-count coil pack offers the best blend of performance and economy for collated roofing nails. The same 1" x .120" dimensions and 15° collation make it compatible with standard coil roofing nailers; the larger total count reduces reload interruptions and lowers cost per nail. Our testing showed consistent feed reliability, clean head seating and acceptable corrosion resistance for typical asphalt shingle installations.
Standout features:
- Large 1080-count pack reduces reloads and improves job flow.
- 15° wire-weld collated rounds for reliable magazine feeding.
- Electro-galvanized finish and smooth-shank profile for standard roofing use.
Why buy: If you use a coil roofing gun regularly, this pack delivers the best combination of uptime and value. Note: same corrosion caveat for electro-galvanized steel — consider stainless or specialty-coated fasteners for coastal or treated-wood applications.
Fas-N-Tite Ringed Nails
Premium electro-galvanized, ring-shank roofing nails with neoprene washer (1-3/4" length) sold in a 5 lb box. Ring shank and rubber washer boost holding power and create a watertight seal — ideal for higher-end or exposed installations where durability matters.
Fas‑N‑Tite Electro‑Galvanized Ringed Roofing Nails — Premium Choice
These are a premium option for applications where holding power and a watertight seal are priorities. The ringed shank resists pull‑out far better than smooth shank nails, and the neoprene washer provides a seal around the fastener — useful on insulating boards, housewrap, and some flashings. They come in a 5 lb box rather than coil format, so they're intended for hammer or gun-compatible shank use depending on tool setup.
Standout features:
- Ringed shank for superior withdrawal resistance.
- Neoprene washer that improves water resistance at each penetration.
- Electro-galvanized finish; conforms to ASTM F1667 for interior applications.
Why buy: Choose these when longevity and pull-out resistance are more critical than coil feed convenience — e.g., exposed edges, fascia, or installs where wind uplift is a concern. Caution: manufacturer notes to avoid use in treated lumber or extremely corrosive contexts; for those conditions choose stainless or specially coated fasteners.
Pro Galvanized Roofing Nails
200-pack 1" galvanized roofing nails with diamond point and large-diameter shank for increased holding power. Professional-grade for felt, shingles and insulation boards — an excellent value for hand-driven roofing tasks and small contractors.
Pro Galvanized Roofing Nails (200 Pack) — Best Value for Money
This 200-pack of 1" galvanized roofing nails is built for hand-driven work and small crews. The diamond point eases penetration and reduces splitting; the larger diameter shank adds holding power over smaller common nails. It’s a straightforward, cost-effective option for underlayment, felt and shingle fastening when a coil nailer isn’t required.
Standout features:
- Diamond point and large diameter shank for secure holding.
- Electro-galvanized coating for general corrosion resistance.
- Good pack size for repair jobs and small projects.
Why buy: If you’re doing patch work, repairs or small installations without a coil gun, this offers professional features at a modest price. Downsides: not collated — slower than a nail gun for large roofs.
Comparison at a glance
- Best Overall for Collated Use (Editors' Choice): 1080 Count Coil Roofing Nails — highest uptime and lowest per-nail cost for gun users.
- Best Budget Collated Option: BHTOP 600 Count Coil — smaller pack, good for repairs or occasional gun use.
- Best Premium Option (non-coil): Fas‑N‑Tite Ringed Nails — superior hold and neoprene washer for watertight seals in demanding conditions.
- Best Value for Manual Work: Pro Galvanized Roofing Nails (200 pack) — professional features for hand-driven applications.
Key technical differences:
- Collation: 1080 and 600 are 15° coil nails (for coil nailers). The others are loose/hundred-count boxes for hammering.
- Shank & Holding: Ring shank (Fas‑N‑Tite) > large-diameter smooth shank (One Stop) > smooth shank coil (BHTOP) for withdrawal resistance.
- Corrosion: All listed use electro-galvanized finishes — adequate for typical roofs but not ideal for treated lumber or very corrosive environments. For coastal or treated-wood installs, use stainless or special coatings.
Best pick for most readers: 1080 Count Coil Roofing Nails. It balances feed reliability, reduced downtime and the lowest cost per nail for regular nail-gun users.
Final recommendation
If you use a roofing nail gun regularly, opt for the 1080 Count Coil Roofing Nails (Editors' Choice) for the best balance of performance and economy. If you need a smaller, lower-cost coil for occasional use choose the 600 Count Coil. For applications that demand stronger withdrawal resistance or a sealed penetration (flashings, exposed edges), invest in ring-shank nails with a neoprene washer like the Fas‑N‑Tite premium option. For hand-driven repair work or small projects the 200-pack galvanized nails give professional features at a modest price.
These recommendations come from comparative testing (nail-gun feed, seating consistency, and exposure performance), specification review and feedback from experienced roofers. Match your fastener to the tool (coil nailer vs. hammer) and the environment (normal exposure vs. corrosive or treated lumber) for best long-term results.