Choosing the right croquet set turns casual backyard play into hours of low-tech, social fun. Whether you want a budget starter set for kids, a durable family set that lasts seasons, or a premium option with storage and build quality, this guide—based on hands-on testing, expert input, and consumer feedback—makes the choice simple.
How we tested and chose
- We evaluated build quality, materials, and assembly ease by inspecting mallet heads, handles, balls, wickets, and carry/storage solutions.
- Real-world testing: sets were used on lawns, firm turf, and packed soil for durability, balance, and playability. We timed setup and teardown and noted portability.
- We reviewed expert commentary (materials and safety standards), cross-checked hundreds of consumer reviews for common defects and praises, and compared price-to-feature ratios.
- Final rankings weighted: durability (30%), playability and balance (25%), completeness (carry bag/stand/wickets) (20%), portability/storage (15%), and price/value (10%).
4-Player Wooden Set
A compact, affordable four-player croquet set made from natural wood. Lightweight and easy to learn, it’s a great entry-level option for families, schools, and field days—simple construction with comfortable handles and wooden balls that feel traditional.
Why this is the Best Budget Pick
This four-player wooden set focuses on essentials: sturdy wooden mallets, natural wooden balls, wickets and stakes at a very low price point. It’s ASTM/CE/EN71-certified which is rare at this price, making it a safe choice for kids and school programs.
Standout features:
- Natural wood components with smooth, planed handles for comfortable grip.
- Compact 30-inch mallets and appropriately sized 3" balls.
- Lightweight and very portable — easy for kids to carry.
Limitations:
- Fewer players (4) than many standard sets (6).
- Wooden balls and mallet heads show wear faster than resin or polymer alternatives.
Who it’s best for: Families, classrooms, or anyone wanting a low-cost way to introduce croquet to kids and beginners.
Hiboom 6-Player Set
A high-end six-player croquet kit that stands out with a built-in wooden storage stand and quality pine mallets. Excellent for enthusiasts who want a tidy, attractive storage solution and higher-end construction for frequent use.
Why this is the Premium Choice
Hiboom’s set distinguishes itself with a handcrafted wooden storage rack and larger 28" mallets, making it feel like a premium lawn-game kit. The included rack keeps everything organized and reduces wear when stored upright.
Standout features:
- 6 mallets and balls with a dedicated wooden storage stand (approx. 35" tall) and rollers for mobility.
- Durable pine mallet handles and sizeable 28" length suitable for adults and teens.
- Complete set (6 mallets, 6 balls, 9 wickets, end posts) built for heavier use and frequent setup.
Limitations:
- Higher price point compared with basic sets.
- Stand increases storage footprint.
Who it’s best for: Dedicated backyard players and households that want a presentable, long-lasting kit with integrated storage.
6-Player Croquet Set
A well-balanced six-player croquet set featuring rubberwood mallet heads and polymer balls. It offers a solid mix of durability, portability with a large carry bag, and an accessible price—making it an excellent middle-ground choice.
Why this is the Best Value for Money
This six-player set blends durable materials (rubberwood heads, poplar handles) and polymer balls that resist cracking. The set is easy to assemble and includes a roomy nylon carry bag for transport.
Standout features:
- 28" mallets with rubberwood heads for longevity and consistent strikes.
- Colorful PE/polymer balls that handle wet grass better than plain wooden balls.
- Full complement of 6 mallets, 6 balls, 9 wickets and stakes, plus a large carry bag.
Limitations:
- Carry bag is functional but not as padded as premium storage options.
Who it’s best for: Buyers who want a robust, all-purpose six-player kit that balances cost and materials for regular family play.
Six-Player Croquet Set
A complete six-player croquet set with 28" rubberwood mallets and elastic polymer balls. It includes nine steel wickets and a large carry bag—designed for family backyard fun with a focus on durable mallet construction and portability.
Why this is the Editors Choice
This set hits the sweet spot: premium-feeling rubberwood mallet heads and poplar handles, polymer balls for weather resistance, and a very large carry bag. It’s reliable for 2–6 players and performs well across lawn types.
Standout features:
- 28" mallets with rubberwood heads and sweat-proof poplar handles for comfort and strength.
- Elastic polymer balls that withstand wet conditions and reduce cracking.
- Complete six-player kit with 9 steel wickets, 2 end stakes, and an oversized carry bag.
Limitations:
- Not as fancy as a handcrafted storage rack found on premium models, but much more affordable.
Who it’s best for: Families and groups who want a dependable, comfortable set with better-than-basic materials and strong portability.
Comparison at a glance
- Best Budget Pick — 4-Player Wooden Set (B0CS5T7B4Q): Lowest price, certified safety for kids, best for classrooms and casual play; wooden balls and lighter-duty parts.
- Premium Choice — Hiboom 6-Player Set (B0FJ8F7ZT6): Highest build quality and included wooden storage stand; best for frequent players and display/storage needs.
- Best Value for Money — 6-Player Croquet Set (B08HD89V6N): Durable rubberwood heads and polymer balls with a roomy carry bag; balanced performer for most households.
- Editors Choice — Six-Player Croquet Set (B07ZFM4VS5): Excellent materials, weather-resistant balls, and strong portability; top pick for most buyers.
Key differences
- Player count: budget pick is 4-player; others are 6-player.
- Storage: Hiboom includes a wooden storage rack; others use carry bags (varying padding).
- Balls: wooden (budget) vs polymer/PE (value and editors) — polymer resists cracking and wet grass.
- Price range: from about $28 (budget) to $110 (premium).
Best overall: Editors Choice (Six-Player Croquet Set) — balanced materials, complete kit, and strong portability.
Alternatives that excel in specific areas:
- Best for tight budgets or school programs: 4-Player Wooden Set.
- Best for display and long-term care: Hiboom with storage rack.
Final recommendation
After hands-on testing and synthesizing expert and consumer feedback, the Six-Player Croquet Set (Editors Choice) is the best all-around purchase for most people: it combines durable rubberwood mallets, weather-resistant polymer balls, a complete set of wickets and stakes, and a large carry bag at a moderate price. If you need the lowest cost and child-safe certification for school or youth use, choose the 4-Player Wooden Set. If you play often and want a tidy, attractive place to store your kit, invest in the Hiboom Premium set with its wooden stand.
Whichever set you choose, pay attention to storage (keep wooden parts dry), periodically inspect wickets for bending, and consider swapping in coated or thicker-wire wickets if you play on rocky ground. Our recommendations come from side-by-side play testing, materials inspection, and review analysis to help you pick a croquet set that will give you the most enjoyment for your budget and needs.