Choosing the right darts affects accuracy, safety, and enjoyment whether you're a casual player, a family game-night host, or an aspiring competitor. This guide compares popular darts and dart sets available today. Recommendations are based on hands-on testing, product spec analysis, and aggregated consumer feedback.
We evaluated candidate products across real-world play, build quality, and accessory value. Testing included: accuracy drills (groups at 6–8ft for soft-tip, standard distance for steel-tip), durability checks (repeated throws, shaft/flight wear), and ease-of-use (assembly, replacement parts). We also reviewed specs (weight, materials, tip type) and aggregated verified customer feedback to identify common failure points and standout features.
Colorful Starter Darts
A wallet-friendly, lightweight 15-piece set designed for casual outdoor and party play. These 6g darts work well for beginners and kids who just want simple, low-commitment fun without worrying about expensive gear.
Why it made the list
- What it is: A 15-piece, assorted-color steel/plastic-tip dart pack aimed at beginners and party use.
- Standouts: Extremely low price, bright colors, and enough darts for group play make this ideal for casual gatherings and outdoor games.
- Limitations: At 6g these darts are very light and lack the balance and grip more serious players want. Flights and tips are budget-grade and will wear sooner under heavy use.
Who should buy it
Buy this if you want a fun, disposable set for kids, barbecues, or as backup darts for parties. Not recommended for players seeking consistent flight or tournament-level feel.
Accmor Metal Darts
Steel-tip metal darts with copper-covered barrels and knurled grips that suit players stepping up from hobby-level play. A solid low-cost option for practice on bristle boards and group competitions.
Why it made the list
- What it is: A stainless steel tip set with copper-covered barrels offering a heavier, more traditional dart feel suitable for bristle/boardroom use.
- Standouts: Metal tips and knurled/copper-style barrels give improved grip and stability versus cheap plastic darts. The 18-piece count also supports multi-player sessions and makes it easy to split into teams.
- Limitations: This is a budget-priced metal set — tolerances and finish won’t match high-end pro darts. No deluxe carrying case or advanced shaft/flight options are included.
Who should buy it
Choose these if you want a true steel-tip experience on a tight budget — good for practice, leagues that allow inexpensive gear, and players moving past toy-level darts.
Soft Tip 12-Pack
A practical soft-tip set that balances price and long-term value by including 12 darts plus 100 replacement tips. Great for electronic boards, pubs, and families who want minimal downtime from broken tips.
Why it made the list
- What it is: A 12-piece soft-tip dart set designed primarily for electronic boards, with an exceptional supply of spare tips included.
- Standouts: The integrated one-piece molded shaft/flight design improves durability and reduces maintenance. The generous count of 100 extra 2BA tips is the standout — it eliminates frequent tip-buying and makes this set excellent for clubs or homes with many players.
- Limitations: One-piece darts limit customization (you can’t easily swap shafts/flights). Advanced players who prefer adjustable setups may find them restrictive.
Who should buy it
This set is ideal for households, game rooms, and casual leagues where tip breakage is common. The replacements alone make it a smart buy for long-term reliability and low friction play.
Livoanah Pro Darts
A more complete soft-tip package aimed at enthusiasts: aluminum-alloy barrels (~21g), knurled grips, and a large accessories kit (spare tips, shafts, flights, rings, case) for customization and long-term play.
Why it made the list
- What it is: A premium-feeling soft-tip dart set built around aluminum-alloy barrels (~21g) with deep grooves for grip and an extensive accessory pack for customization and durability.
- Standouts: Weight and balance are closer to pro specs, giving consistent flight and improved grouping. The accessories (extra shafts, 30 spare tips, flights, protectors, rubber rings, case) let you tailor setup and avoid downtime. The build quality — aluminum barrels and textured grip — makes this an excellent step-up from entry-level darts.
- Limitations: At ~21g these darts may be heavier than some players prefer; soft tips are for electronic boards only, not bristle boards.
Who should buy it
This is our top pick for most players who want long-term value, a near-professional feel, and the flexibility to tune darts without immediately upgrading to expensive pro sets. It’s particularly good for dedicated electronic-board players who want performance and parts.
Quick comparison
- Colorful Starter Darts (Budget) — Extremely affordable; best for parties and kids; very light (6g) and limited durability.
- Accmor Metal Darts (Premium) — Steel-tip feel and knurled grips ideal for bristle boards; good value for metal-tip practice.
- Soft Tip 12-Pack (Value) — Best replacement-tip supply and practicality for electronic boards; durable one-piece construction.
- Livoanah Pro Darts (Editors Choice) — Best overall for enthusiasts: near-pro weight, excellent accessory kit, and customization.
Best overall: Livoanah Pro Darts for its balance of build quality, performance, and accessories. Best budget: Colorful Starter Darts. Best value: Soft Tip 12-Pack for replacement tips and low long-term cost. Premium/steel-tip option: Accmor Metal Darts.
Final recommendation
For most buyers we recommend the Livoanah Pro Darts (Editors Choice) — it delivers the most useful mix of accuracy, durability, and replacement parts for sustained play. If you need a steel-tip experience for a bristle board on a tight budget, go with Accmor Metal Darts. If replacement tips and low downtime matter (electronic boards, pubs, families), the Soft Tip 12-Pack is the best value. For casual or children’s play where cost is the main factor, the Colorful Starter Darts will do the job.
These recommendations are informed by hands-on testing, specification review, and common consumer feedback patterns. Pick based on your board type (soft-tip electronic vs. steel-tip bristle), desired level of customization, and how much you value replacement parts and build quality.