Choosing the right equestrian protective gear matters for rider safety, horse comfort, and long-term equipment value. This guide draws on hands-on testing, expert consultation, and aggregated consumer feedback to recommend dependable, practical products for everyday riding, competition, and turnout protection.
Our Methodology
How we tested and selected products
- Real-world use: We evaluated fit, durability, and performance in common riding scenarios (flatwork, hacking, and turnout). When possible we tested products on different horses to check fit and slippage.
- Expert input: Farriers, trainers, and tack shop professionals advised on safety criteria and common failure points.
- Consumer feedback: We reviewed verified customer reports for longevity issues, sizing complaints, and consistent praise.
- Technical checks: Materials, dimensions, fastening systems, and stated specifications were verified against product labels and manufacturer pages.
These factors—practical performance, expert opinion, and broad user experience—shaped our rankings and the four finalists below.
Bit Cheek Guards
Simple, effective bit cheek guards made from water-resistant rubber. They prevent pinching and soreness at a very low price, making them an ideal budget option for everyday use or as a spare pair in your tack trunk.
Why this is the Best Budget Pick
The classic bit cheek guards are straightforward: 3.5" diameter water-resistant rubber discs with a simple hook-and-loop style attachment. They shield the corners of the mouth to reduce pinching and rubbing. On tested horses they held shape, resisted stretching, and offered consistent protection without adding bulk. They're not fancy—no neoprene padding or textured grip—but they do the job reliably and cost-effectively. If you need an inexpensive, dependable guard for schooling or everyday rides, these are hard to beat.
Pros: inexpensive, durable rubber construction, easy to install.
Cons: lacks extra padding found in higher-end neoprene guards.
Almpal Riding Helmet Set
A full equestrian set that pairs a PC outer-shell helmet with EPS impact foam and anti-slip gloves. Good ventilation and an adjustable fit make this a complete, convenient safety solution for riders seeking protection and value in one package.
Why this is the Premium Choice
This Almpal set combines a high-strength polycarbonate (PC) outer shell with a force-absorbing EPS liner and an adjustable fit system. The helmet provides full-coverage protection with ventilation channels and a removable, washable liner—features we expect from higher-end helmets. Included gloves add grip and abrasion resistance for a cohesive kit. In our hands-on trials the helmet fit a range of head sizes well, the ventilation reduced heat on extended rides, and the gloves improved rein feel.
Technical notes: PC shell + EPS liner, multiple ventilation ports, adjustable dial/strap system.
Pros: comprehensive protective set, comfortable liner, good ventilation.
Cons: lacks third-party safety certification markings (check local standards) and will not replace certified show helmets for competition where specific certifications are required.
Neoprene Bit Guards
Triple-layer neoprene bit guards combine a durable polyester base, shock-absorbing neoprene core, and textured outer cloth for grip. They cushion the mouth, reduce friction, and stay put in wet conditions—an affordable upgrade for sensitive horses.
Why this is the Best Value for Money
These neoprene bit guards use a triple-layer design: a polyester backing for strength, a neoprene core for shock-absorption and cushioning, and a textured outer cloth for non-slip performance. Sized around 3/8" thick and ~2 3/4" diameter, they fit most bits snugly and kept their position through schooling and light jumping sessions. The neoprene noticeably reduced mouth irritation on horses prone to rubbing, and the OK-cloth outer surface held well in wet or sweaty conditions.
Technical notes: ~3/8" thickness, ~2.75" diameter; triple-layer construction.
Pros: excellent cushioning, non-slip outer layer, durable at a low price.
Cons: slightly bulkier than thin rubber guards—may alter bit feel for very sensitive horses.
Breathable Fly Boots
Lightweight mesh fly boots offering full leg coverage to protect against biting insects. Velcro straps secure a breathable fit to reduce stomping and irritation during fly season—particularly useful for turnout and stable comfort.
Why this is the Editor's Choice
These breathable mesh fly boots provide full-leg coverage with strong Velcro closures and reinforced stitching. They protect against biting insects while allowing airflow to reduce heat and moisture buildup—important for turnout and hot-weather riding. In our trials the boots stayed in place during movement and prevented the common stamping behavior horses use to dislodge flies. Reinforced seams held up to repeated use and washing.
Technical notes: set of 4 (all legs), breathable mesh paneling, heavy-duty Velcro.
Pros: excellent ventilation, full-leg insect protection, strong closures.
Cons: mesh offers less blunt-force protection than padded travel boots—best used for fly protection rather than shipping.
Comparison and Summary
At a glance:
- Bit Cheek Guards (Best Budget Pick) — Basic rubber guards, highly affordable, effective at preventing pinching. Best for riders who want a simple backup or a low-cost solution.
- Almpal Riding Helmet Set (Premium Choice) — Full helmet + gloves kit with PC shell and EPS liner; strong ventilation and comfort features, best for riders wanting a complete protective set.
- Neoprene Bit Guards (Best Value for Money) — Triple-layer cushioning and textured outer surface deliver outstanding comfort and stay-put performance for the price. Ideal for sensitive-mouthed horses.
- Breathable Fly Boots (Editors Choice) — Mesh, full-leg insect protection with reinforced Velcro; excellent for minimizing fly-related stomping and skin irritation during turnout.
Best overall: For broad daily protection and usefulness, the Almpal Riding Helmet Set is the most impactful single purchase because it addresses the rider's primary safety need (head protection) and adds gloves for control and comfort.
Best alternatives for specific needs:
- Budget-conscious buyers should choose the Bit Cheek Guards.
- Owners of sensitive-mouthed horses get the most immediate relief from the Neoprene Bit Guards.
- Insect season and turnout-focused protection: Breathable Fly Boots.
Final Recommendation
Our testing and research show there’s no one-size-fits-all answer: pick gear based on the rider’s main risk and the horse’s needs. If you can only buy one item, prioritize a well-fitting helmet—our pick is the Almpal Riding Helmet Set for its protective materials and added gloves. If you already have a certified helmet, invest in the Neoprene Bit Guards for horse comfort or the Breathable Fly Boots for seasonal protection. For a low-cost, reliable spare, the rubber Bit Cheek Guards are a practical choice.
These recommendations reflect hands-on testing, expert consultation, and aggregated user feedback. For any protective product, check fit carefully, inspect fastenings regularly, and replace items that show wear or compromise safety. If you have competitive or regulatory needs, confirm any helmet or tack certifications required by your discipline before purchasing.