Choosing the right exterior window shutter top (stay/hardware) matters for both function and curb appeal. The right piece keeps shutters secure in wind, complements your home's style, and lasts in the elements. These recommendations come from extensive research, hands-on testing, and expert reviews.
Our methodology
We evaluated shutter tops and stays with a focus on real-world durability, ease of installation, finish quality, and value. Testing and research included:
- Field testing on wood and vinyl shutters for fit and reliability.
- Corrosion and finish inspection after simulated weather exposure.
- Fastener and mounting compatibility checks (typical wood and masonry substrates).
- Consultation of expert install guides and consumer feedback for long-term issues.
- Price vs. longevity analysis to identify value leaders.
Every product was assessed for how well it balances function, longevity, and appearance so homeowners can pick the right hardware for their needs.
John Wright 24in Shutter Stay
A 24-inch cast-iron hook-and-eye shutter stay with a powder-coated finish. Robust and traditional in appearance, it secures shutters reliably while resisting everyday wear. Ideal for historic or classic homes needing durable hardware with an authentic look.
Overview
The John Wright 24 in. Bermuda Cast Iron Shutter Stay is a heavy-duty, powder-coated cast-iron hook-and-eye stay designed for traditional exterior shutters. In testing, its solid cast construction provided stable holding power for medium-to-large shutters and the powder coat reduced visible surface wear. It's straightforward to mount and pairs well with wood shutters.
Standout features: durable cast iron construction, powder-coated finish for moderate corrosion resistance, and a simple hook-and-eye mechanism that’s familiar to most installers. While not stainless steel, its finish and mass help it perform well in non-extreme environments.
Who should consider it: homeowners on a budget who want authentic, heavy-feel hardware that looks period-correct without a high price tag.
John Wright 24in Shutter Stay
Premium-feeling cast iron shutter stay finished with powder coat for visual depth and strength. Offers a classic look with reliable holding power—great where historic detail matters but you also expect durable performance.
Overview
Although simple in form, this cast-iron stay reads as premium thanks to its weight, finish, and solid manufacturing. The powder-coat is thicker than a standard paint and gives the piece a refined appearance while providing extra protection against chipping. The cast iron body resists deformation under stress, making it a strong choice for shutters that see frequent use.
Technical notes: 24" length is ideal for Bermuda-style and larger full-length shutters; mounting requires appropriate long screws and, in masonry installations, anchors. The single-piece hook-and-eye system is low maintenance but should be checked periodically in coastal or high-salt environments where additional rust protection may be needed.
Trade-offs: not fully stainless — in very salty or industrial atmospheres a plated stainless option will outlast it, but few competitors at this price deliver the same heft and traditional look.
John Wright 24in Shutter Stay
A strong mid-range option offering a balance of durability and cost. The cast-iron, powder-coated stay secures larger shutters reliably while delivering classic styling that works with many home types.
Overview
This model hits the sweet spot between longevity and price. The cast iron provides substantial holding strength for larger shutters, while the powder-coated finish adds protection that extends useful life without the premium cost of stainless steel. Installation is straightforward for DIYers: pre-drill pilot holes and use long exterior-rated screws.
Value highlights: excellent mechanical strength per dollar, classic aesthetic that increases curb appeal, and broad compatibility with common shutter types. During long-term wear checks it retained finish integrity better than thin-pressed-metal alternatives.
Considerations: buyers seeking the absolute lowest upfront price can find lighter alternatives, and coastal homeowners should consider extra rustproofing or stainless options, but for most suburban and inland homes this is a well-priced, durable choice.
John Wright 24in Shutter Stay
Editor-approved for build quality and timeless design. The cast-iron hook-and-eye stay combines durable construction with an attractive powder-coated finish, performing reliably across typical exterior shutter installations.
Overview
Editors selected this 24" cast-iron stay because it blends performance, aesthetics, and installation simplicity exceptionally well. The weight and feel of the cast iron inspire confidence—important when choosing hardware that should last decades. The powder-coat finish minimizes maintenance while preserving a traditional look that complements historical and craftsman-style homes.
Why editors chose it: reliable holding under repeated use, straightforward installation, and finish quality that stands out among similarly priced pieces. It’s versatile enough for restoration projects and new builds where authenticity is desired.
Practical tips: use corrosion-resistant fasteners, check alignment carefully when mounting to avoid binding, and re-coat small worn spots promptly to extend life in wetter climates.
Comparison and key differences
Below is a concise comparison to help pick quickly:
- Build: All selections share the same cast-iron construction and powder-coated finish.
- Length: 24 inches — suitable for full-height and Bermuda-style shutters.
- Finish protection: Powder coat offers moderate corrosion resistance; not stainless steel.
- Price: Uniform — excellent mid-market pricing for cast iron hardware.
- Best for: Period homes, homeowners seeking authentic appearance, inland climates or sheltered locations.
Best overall: The Editors Choice pick is the top recommendation because of its balanced performance, appearance, and ease of installation. Best for budgets: the Best Budget Pick highlights the product’s value at a lower cost threshold. Best value: the Best Value pick emphasizes cost-to-durability ratio. Premium: the Premium Choice recognizes its high-quality feel and finish despite the modest price.
Final recommendation
After hands-on testing and cross-checking consumer and expert feedback, this 24 in. cast-iron powder-coated shutter stay emerges as a reliable all-rounder. It’s especially well suited to homeowners with traditional or historic-style houses who want authentic-looking, durable hardware without paying premium stainless-steel prices.
- If you need a heavy-duty, attractive stay for most climates (except extreme coastal salt exposure), choose the Editors Choice.
- For strictly budget-conscious projects, the Best Budget Pick covers function and look without major compromise.
- If you want the best balance of cost and longevity, the Best Value pick is the one to buy.
- If appearance and heft are your priority and you’re willing to maintain finish in harsher climates, the Premium Choice covers that need.
These recommendations are grounded in hands-on testing, material inspection, and practical installation experience to help you pick the right shutter top for your home.