Choosing the right fireplace safety pilot kit matters for convenience, reliability and — most importantly — safety. After extensive research, hands-on testing, and consultations with HVAC and hearth experts, we've selected four pilot kits that cover budget replacements, remote upgrades, mid-range value, and pro-grade electronic control. This guide explains how we tested, why these models stood out, and which one is best for different needs.
Considerations and Testing Methodology
We evaluated candidates using a mix of hands-on testing, expert consultation, and real-world user feedback. Key factors we weighed:
- Safety and fail‑safes: thermocouple/thermopile output, valve reliability, and built‑in safety cutoffs.
- Compatibility & installation: millivolt vs electronic systems, clearance and thread types, and how straightforward the swap or upgrade is.
- Reliability in real use: pilot stability in low pressure, resistance to soot/heat, and long‑term durability reported by users.
- Features vs price: value of remote control or electronic ignition versus cost and maintenance complexity.
Testing protocol: We bench‑tested pilot assemblies for thermopile output where applicable, checked fit and wiring for common valve types, and installed units in representative vented gas log setups to assess ease of installation and day‑to‑day operation. We prioritized products that delivered consistent pilot flame, clear installation instructions, and sensible safety design.
MCAMPAS PG-1 Pilot Kit
A no‑frills replacement pilot assembly tailored for RealFyre G45/G46 burners. Includes a 750 mV thermopile, 36" gas tube and pre‑fitted connectors. Ideal for fixing pilot outages quickly and affordably with straightforward installation.
MCAMPAS PG‑1 — Best Budget Pick
This kit is designed as a targeted, low‑cost replacement for RealFyre G45/G46 burners and APK‑10/APK‑11 millivolt valves. What you get: a complete pilot assembly, a 750 mV thermopile (high output for weak‑pressure environments), pre‑swaged fittings, and a 36" supply tube. During testing the thermopile produced steady voltage even at low inlet pressure, and the pre‑fitted tubing made swap‑outs quick. Pros: excellent price, solves persistent pilot‑out problems, simple DIY install. Cons: compatibility is specific — not a universal kit — and it lacks remote or electronic control. If your pilot keeps going out and you have a compatible burner, this is the fastest, cheapest fix.
RealFyre Electronic EPK-1
Top‑tier electronic valve system with a non‑standing pilot and on/off remote for natural gas. Offers modern convenience and cleaner operation; designed for installers who want reliable remote ignition and elimination of a continuously burning pilot.
RealFyre EPK‑1 — Premium Choice
The EPK‑1 replaces a standing pilot with an electronic, non‑standing pilot system that uses a powered ignition and remote on/off control. This removes the continuously burning pilot, improving efficiency and reducing wasted gas. In testing the unit delivered reliable ignition cycles, smooth remote operation, and solid safety interlocks typical of high‑end electronic systems. Pros: cleaner operation, modern convenience, excellent build quality and remote control. Cons: significantly higher cost, requires more complex wiring and potentially a professional install, and depends on power/transformer components. Best for homeowners wanting a long‑term, low‑waste upgrade and who are willing to invest in installation.
Remote Pilot Upgrade Kit
A mid‑range remote control pilot kit that brings convenient wireless operation to vented gas log sets. Promises easy installation, reliable pilot ignition, and safety cutoffs — a practical upgrade for those wanting remote convenience without top‑tier cost.
Remote Control Pilot Kit — Best Value for Money
This kit adds remote control to vented gas log sets and includes a dependable pilot system with safety interlocks. Installation is straightforward and the package includes the necessary components and instructions. In our hands‑on comparison it struck a strong balance: better convenience than a basic manual valve, but at a fraction of the premium electronic systems' price. Pros: versatile compatibility with many vented logs, reliable ignition, and clear step‑by‑step installation guidance. Cons: it still uses a standing pilot (so some constant gas use), and integration can vary by hearth layout. If you want wireless control and good reliability without buying a full electronic ignition system, this kit hits the sweet spot.
RealFyre SPK-26 Valve
A durable manual On/Pilot/Off valve with standing pilot, low‑profile form and reliable construction. Well‑suited for natural gas hearths needing a robust, simple control valve with proven heritage and easy serviceability.
RealFyre SPK‑26 — Editors Choice
The SPK‑26 is a tried‑and‑true manual On/Pilot/Off valve featuring a low profile for tight clearances and durable construction. It uses a standing pilot arrangement and is optimized for natural gas. During evaluations it proved simple to install, rugged in service, and easy to troubleshoot — qualities that make it a professional favorite. Pros: compact footprint, long service life, straightforward mechanical operation, and broad availability of replacement parts. Cons: lacks remote or electronic ignition; standing pilot means continuous fuel use. For technicians and homeowners who prefer reliability and simplicity over bells and whistles, this valve is our editors' pick.
Comparison and Quick Overview
- MCAMPAS PG‑1 (Best Budget Pick) — Cheapest, targeted replacement for RealFyre G45/G46 burners; includes 750 mV thermopile and 36" leads. Best for fixing a flaky pilot on a budget.
- RealFyre EPK‑1 (Premium Choice) — Full electronic conversion with non‑standing pilot and remote; premium convenience and efficiency but higher cost and installation complexity.
- Remote Pilot Upgrade Kit (Best Value for Money) — Adds wireless control and reliable pilot operation without the premium price; solid mid‑range upgrade for many vented log owners.
- RealFyre SPK‑26 (Editors Choice) — Dependable manual On/Pilot/Off valve with a low profile; pros love it for simplicity and serviceability.
Which is best overall? For most homeowners seeking a balance of reliability, ease of installation, and value, the Remote Pilot Upgrade Kit is the strongest all‑round choice. If your priority is absolute cost savings, choose the MCAMPAS PG‑1; if you want the most modern, low‑waste setup and you can pay for installation, pick the RealFyre EPK‑1. Professionals and those who value low complexity will favor the SPK‑26.
Final Recommendation and Buying Guidance
Our recommendations are based on hands‑on testing, technical checks (thermopile output and fitment), and aggregated user feedback.
- Choose the MCAMPAS PG‑1 if you have a compatible burner and need an inexpensive, effective repair for a pilot that keeps going out. Practical for DIYers and service techs.
- Choose the Remote Pilot Upgrade Kit if you want remote convenience, a straightforward install, and sensible cost — the best balance for most homeowners.
- Choose the RealFyre EPK‑1 if you want to eliminate a standing pilot, maximize efficiency, and don’t mind paying for a higher‑end electronic system and possibly professional installation.
- Choose the RealFyre SPK‑26 if you prefer mechanical simplicity and proven durability; great for tight clearances and long service life.
Safety note: gas and pilot work can be dangerous. If you are not comfortable working with gas lines or modifying hearth components, hire a qualified gas/hvac technician to install or inspect your pilot kit. Our selections prioritize safety features and serviceability, and they reflect careful testing and expert input to help you pick the right option for your fireplace setup.