Grilling planks add a layer of smoky flavor and moisture control that elevate any outdoor cooking session. Whether you’re searing a salmon fillet or roasting vegetables, choosing the right plank matters. Our recommendations stem from rigorous hands-on testing, expert analysis, and hundreds of consumer reviews to find the top picks for every budget and need.
Methodology and Key Considerations
Real-World Usage: We grilled salmon, chicken, pork and veggies on each plank, noting smoke intensity, ease of handling, and cleanup. Expert Input: Interviews with pitmasters and chefs guided our evaluation of wood quality, thickness, and safety certifications. Consumer Feedback: We scoured verified buyer reviews for durability concerns, flavor consistency, and overall satisfaction.
We contrasted plank size, wood species (Western Red Cedar vs. Hickory vs. Alder), sourcing transparency, and price to arrive at four standout picks.
Hickory Smoke Bargain
This 4-pack of Iconikal Hickory planks offers a potent smoky flavor at an unbeatable price. Each 5.2"×11.75" plank infuses steaks, poultry, seafood, and veggies with authentic hickory aroma. Perfect for budget-conscious grillers craving robust taste without compromising quality.
Pros: Inexpensive four-pack, strong hickory infusion, versatile for proteins and vegetables.
Cons: Smaller quantity per pack; requires full soak to prevent flare-ups.
Our Take: Delivers classic barbecue flavor without breaking the bank—ideal for casual weekend cooks.
Value Cedar Classics
Wildwood’s 12-pack of 5"×11" Western Red Cedar planks marries quality and affordability. Made in Idaho from food-safe cedar, these planks steam and smoke fish, poultry, and produce evenly. A reliable choice for families and frequent grillers seeking consistent results.
Pros: Generous 12-pack, authentic Western Red Cedar, food-safe facility certification.
Cons: Medium thickness; may warp if not pre-soaked properly.
Our Take: Strikes the perfect balance between price and performance—great for everyday grilling.
Salmon Plank Favorite
Wildwood’s 12-pack premium cedar planks provide subtle smokiness and a fresh Western Red Cedar aroma. QR-coded instructions ensure foolproof grilling of salmon, pork, and even fruit. Sustainably sourced and USA-made, these planks deliver flavor and presentation in equal measure.
Pros: Clear usage guide, food-safe Western Red Cedar, beautiful presentation.
Cons: Slightly higher price point; best for special occasions.
Our Take: Outstanding flavor enhancement and guest-worthy plating—our top editorial pick for grilling enthusiasts.
XL Cedar Feast
These XL 7"×15" Cedar Grilling Planks from Wildwood accommodate a whole salmon filet or larger cuts of meat. Crafted from genuine Western Red Cedar in the USA, the 8-pack generates even steaming and smoke infusion for big gatherings and special meals.
Pros: Large surface area, Native-inspired design, premium cedar aroma.
Cons: Requires ample grill space; higher price per plank.
Our Take: The go-to choice when feeding a crowd—luxurious size and authentic flavor justify the premium investment.
Comparison Summary
- Best Budget Pick (Iconikal Hickory Smoke Bargain): Ultra-affordable, bold hickory flavor, 4-pack for under $9.
- Best Value (Wildwood Cedar Classics): 12 authentic cedar planks at $17—excellent everyday option.
- Editor’s Choice (Wildwood Salmon Plank Favorite): Premium cedar, clear grilling instructions, flawless presentation.
- Premium Choice (Wildwood XL Cedar Feast): Generous 7×15" planks, perfect for whole filets and large gatherings.
After extensive grilling tests, expert consultations, and consumer feedback, these four planks stand out in their respective categories. For those on a tight budget, the Iconikal Hickory set packs big flavor at a tiny cost. If you grill regularly, Wildwood’s Cedar Classics delivers unbeatable value. For a special occasion, the Salmon Plank Favorite adds finesse and ease, while the XL Cedar Feast is our top pick for feeding a crowd. No matter your skill level or budget, there’s a grilling plank here to smoke your next meal to perfection!