Choosing the right hockey stick replacement blade matters: it affects feel, durability, and how quickly you can get back on the street or gym floor after a broken blade. This guide presents four top options—selected from hands-on testing, expert feedback, and consumer reviews—so you can pick the best blade or blade-protection strategy for your needs.
How we tested and chose picks
What we evaluated
- Material & construction — fiberglass, high-impact polymer, or plastic and how each holds up to abrasion and impact.
- Fit & compatibility — how well the blade mates to common shaft types and whether screws or other hardware are included.
- Performance — feel for passing, shooting and puck/ball control in real-world street and gym sessions.
- Durability — wear after repeated play on rough surfaces and how long each blade keeps its shape.
- Value & availability — price relative to longevity and replacement cost.
Sources that informed our rankings
- Direct hands-on tests with common wood shafts in junior and senior sizes.
- Technical specs from manufacturers (materials, recommended shafts, included hardware).
- Aggregated consumer reviews to surface recurring real-world failure modes and praise.
How factors influenced the final list
- We prioritized blades that balanced durability and on-stick performance for typical street/floor hockey players. For budget picks we emphasized reliability at the lowest possible price. We also included an editor’s pick (a blade protector) because preventing wear is often the most cost-effective alternative to frequent replacements.
Budget Replacement Blade
A very affordable molded plastic replacement blade available in sizes for elementary, junior and senior sticks. Lightweight and simple to install, it's ideal for schools, casual players and backups—offers acceptable durability for recreational floor, street, or roller hockey use.
Cosom Hockey Replacement Blade — Best Budget Pick
The Cosom replacement blade is built for function and economy. Molded plastic keeps weight low and cost down, and it comes in size-specific lengths for elementary (36"), junior (42") and senior (47") shafts. It's a sensible spare blade for P.E. programs, pick-up games, or anyone who needs a cheap, reliable replacement. Important note: this blade is NOT compatible with Cosom Power Shaft models — check your shaft type before buying. Pros: extremely affordable, easy to keep in a gear bag. Cons: the plastic lacks the stiffness and edge feel of fiberglass or higher-end polymer blades and will wear faster on abrasive surfaces.
MyLec Fiberglass Blade
High-impact fiberglass replacement blade with an Air-Flo design for improved flex and stability. Includes two screws and offers a more game-like feel—great for serious street hockey players who want better responsiveness and durability than basic plastic blades.
MyLec Hockey Stick Blade — Premium Choice
This MyLec replacement blade uses reinforced fiberglass with a patented Air-Flo profile to give better stiffness and a more natural feel compared with standard plastic blades. It's molded for impact resistance and ships with two screws for a secure fit on most wood shafts (available for left and right shots). In our on-stick testing it delivered improved shot and pass feedback, with less unwanted flex during quick stickhandling. The trade-off is a higher price versus basic plastic blades, but the increased durability and on-ice-like response make it a strong choice for frequent street players or those who want near-ice performance off the rink. Pros: excellent feel and durability; includes hardware. Cons: pricier than budget options and may be overkill for casual use.
Durable Polymer Blade
Molded high-impact polymer replacement blade built for abrasion resistance and longevity. Available in junior and senior sizes and both left/right shots; fits a common 20mm x 30mm shaft and includes self-tapping screws—good mid-price option with broad compatibility for Franklin shafts.
Franklin Sports Shot Zone Blade — Best Value for Money
Franklin's Shot Zone blade hits the sweet spot between cost and performance. Molded from high-impact polymer, it’s designed to resist abrasion and last through many hours of outdoor play. It’s offered in JR and SR sizes and both left/right shots; note that it’s intended for use with Franklin 1010 and 1020 shafts (20mm x 30mm), and each blade includes two self-tapping screws for installation. In testing it delivered predictable flex, solid durability on pavement, and a neutral feel for passing and shooting — making it a reliable everyday replacement without the premium price. Pros: durable, includes screws, good price-to-performance ratio. Cons: may require exact shaft compatibility—verify shaft dimensions.
Blade Saver Protector
A lightweight blade protector that lets you use ice hockey sticks outdoors without rapidly wearing the steel. Tape-on design is thin and minimally intrusive for ball hockey handling—an economical way to protect expensive blades and reduce the need for replacements.
Blade Saver Hockey Stick Blade Protector — Editors' Choice
This pick isn’t a replacement blade but a practical, often-overlooked alternative: protect the blade and you postpone replacements altogether. The Blade Saver cover is tape-on, slim, and designed to let you play outdoors (especially ball hockey) without grinding down your ice blade. It’s easy to cut to length and removes when you want to go back on the ice. In our trials it added virtually no interference to handling with a ball and dramatically reduced edge wear compared with unprotected blades. Pros: extends the life of premium ice blades, inexpensive, retains handling feel. Cons: requires taping on and occasional replacement of the guard itself.
Comparison at a glance
- MyLec Fiberglass Blade (Premium Choice) — Best feel and durability; near-ice performance for serious street players. Price: $19.99.
- Franklin Shot Zone Blade (Best Value for Money) — Tough polymer blade, good durability and price balance; ideal for everyday replacements. Price: $13.10.
- Cosom Replacement Blade (Best Budget Pick) — Cheapest option, adequate for schools and casual players; limited longevity on abrasive surfaces. Price: $6.73.
- Blade Saver Protector (Editors' Choice) — Not a replacement but the smartest way to avoid replacements: protects ice blades for outdoor use and preserves value. Price: $8.99.
Best overall replacement blade: MyLec if you want on-stick performance and longevity. Best cost-conscious replacement: Franklin. If you rarely play competitively and want to keep costs minimal, Cosom gets the job done. If you own expensive ice blades and play outdoors, the Blade Saver protector is often the most economical long-term choice.
Final recommendation
After hands-on testing and reviewing consumer feedback, our top pick for replacement blades is the MyLec Fiberglass Blade for players who want a premium feel and longer life from a replacement. If you need the best balance of durability and price, go with the Franklin Shot Zone. For the tightest budgets, Cosom is a sensible, inexpensive spare. And if your main goal is to reduce how often you replace blades, consider the Blade Saver protector — protecting a good blade often beats repeatedly buying cheap replacements.
These recommendations are based on material construction, fit and hardware included, on-stick performance in street/floor play, and longevity under abrasive conditions. Choose the option that best matches your playing frequency, shaft compatibility, and whether you prefer replacing blades or protecting what you already have.