Choosing the right ashtray matters more than you might think—whether you want to keep patios tidy, protect indoor air from odors, or add a durable smoking accessory to your home. These recommendations come from hands-on testing, expert evaluation, and a review of consumer feedback to find the best ashtrays available today.
Considerations
Before picking winners we tested and evaluated dozens of candidates using a consistent set of criteria. Key factors we weighed:
- Wind & odor control — effectiveness of lids, depth, and containment in real outdoor breezes.
- Material & durability — stainless steel, ceramic, silicone and metal finishes for rust resistance and drop performance.
- Ease of cleaning — removable parts, dishwasher-safe materials, and how soot or residue wipes away.
- Functionality — number/size of rests for cigarettes/cigars, central extinguishing platforms, and non-scratch bottoms.
- Aesthetics & size — how well the ashtray integrates into patios, bars, or living rooms.
- Value & packaging — price vs. features, multi-packs, and gift-ready presentation.
Our hands-on process included wind-shelter tests outdoors, smoke-escape/odor checks, drop and heat resistance assessments, and evaluation of cleaning in everyday conditions. Final rankings were also informed by aggregated user reviews and brand reliability.
Stainless Steel 2-Pack
A compact, no-nonsense stainless steel ashtray set. Durable, easy to clean, and budget-friendly—this two-pack is ideal for households that want reliable, low-maintenance ashtrays that won’t scratch tabletops and come in multiple colors and sizes.
Best Budget Pick — Stainless Steel 2-Pack (Small)
This two-pack delivers dependable performance for the lowest price. Made from stainless steel with a smooth bottom to avoid table scratches, these ashtrays are lightweight yet sturdy and easy to rinse clean. The simple edge design holds cigarettes securely; the compact footprint works well on coffee tables, balconies, or in bars. Expect minimal frills—no lid—so they’re best where wind and strong odors aren’t a major concern. Tech details: stainless construction, smooth base, available in multiple sizes and colors.
Pros:
- Extremely affordable and durable
- Easy to clean, smooth finish
- Two per pack adds convenience
Cons:
- No lid or odor containment
- Best for sheltered or indoor use
OILP Windproof Cigar Ashtray
A robust, windproof cigar ashtray designed for outdoor use. Large holder, detachable central column for easy cleaning, and an anti-skid base make it a comfortable, premium-feeling accessory for cigar enthusiasts who want durability and functionality.
Premium Choice — OILP Windproof Cigar Ashtray
This model aims squarely at cigar lovers who want a premium, purpose-built ashtray. The heavy-duty design includes four wide cigar rests, a central removable pillar for extinguishing and easy cleaning, and a lid that locks in ashes and keeps rain out. The anti-skid bottom and hand-oiled black finish deliver a refined look that doubles as décor on a patio or study. In testing it handled wind and light rain well and the detachable column simplified cleaning. Tech details: detachable central column, 4 wide rests, anti-skid base, windproof lid, hand-finished exterior.
Pros:
- Well-suited for cigars and larger ring gauges
- Good wind/rain protection and easy maintenance
- Stylish, gift-ready presentation
Cons:
- Higher price than simple trays
- Bulkier footprint for small tables
Windproof Outdoor Ashtray
A windproof stainless-steel ashtray with a wooden lid that keeps ashes and smells contained. Rust-resistant, dishwasher safe, and designed with three grooves for cigarette rests—an excellent mid-priced option for both patios and indoor tabletops.
Best Value — Windproof Stainless Ashtray with Wood Lid
This ashtray hits the sweet spot between cost and capability. Constructed from rust-resistant stainless steel with an elegant wood lid, it traps ash and minimizes odors while the lid prevents ashes from scattering in wind. We found it cleans easily (dishwasher safe in most cases), resists heat and staining, and the three-groove rim gives stable holds for cigarettes. It’s a versatile choice for indoor and outdoor use when you want odor control without paying a premium.
Pros:
- Excellent wind and odor containment for the price
- Durable stainless construction and dishwasher safe
- Attractive, understated design
Cons:
- Wood lid may require occasional cleaning to avoid stains
- Not specialized for large cigars
Metal Smokeless Ashtray
A versatile metal smokeless ashtray with a lid and central platform that reduces smoke escape and odors. Available in multiple sizes and colors; features a protective pad on the bottom and an easy-to-disassemble interior for cleaning.
Editor's Choice — Metal Windproof Smokeless Ashtray
This ashtray earns the top spot for balancing performance, looks, and value. The lid and central platform design significantly reduce smoke escape and odor, which we confirmed during indoor and outdoor tests. The unit is made of high-quality metal, includes a protective pad to prevent tabletop scratches, and disassembles for thorough cleaning—features rarely found together at this price point. Multiple color and size options make it a flexible pick whether you want a small desktop model or a larger patio piece. Tech details: metal construction, rotating/disassemblable central platform, anti-scratch pad, available in 4 sizes and multiple finishes.
Pros:
- Best overall smoke and odor containment
- Easy to clean and maintain
- Stylish and available in several sizes
Cons:
- Small sizes may feel too compact for large gatherings
- Metal finish can show fingerprints
Comparison and Summary
Below is a quick comparison to help you choose:
- Best Budget Pick — Stainless Steel 2-Pack (B09ZTLCK5M): Cheapest option, durable stainless steel, two units per pack. Best for sheltered indoor use and tight budgets.
- Premium Choice — OILP Windproof Cigar Ashtray (B0F4DHQKLP): Built for cigar enthusiasts — detachable column, wide rests, lid for rain/wind protection, high-end finish.
- Best Value for Money — Windproof Stainless with Wood Lid (B0DTQ9RBV7): Great balance of price and capability with effective odor/wind control and dishwasher-safe construction.
- Editor’s Choice — Metal Smokeless Ashtray (B0CCPLGL5C): Top overall performer — lid + central platform for smoke containment, easy cleaning, anti-scratch base, multiple sizes.
Best overall: Editors Choice (Metal Smokeless Ashtray) — it offers the most complete combination of smoke containment, durability, and ease of cleaning. If you primarily smoke cigars, choose the Premium OILP. If you need the lowest cost per unit, go with the 2-pack stainless steel. For the best mix of features at a mid-range price, the windproof stainless ashtray with wood lid is the smart pick.
Final Recommendation
All four picks were chosen after hands-on testing, customer review aggregation, and durability checks. If you want one solid recommendation for most households and patios, buy the Editor’s Choice metal smokeless ashtray — it performs best in both indoor and outdoor settings and is easy to maintain. Choose the OILP model if you favor a cigar-specific, premium experience. For tight budgets, the two-pack stainless set gives great durability at the lowest price, and the wood-lidded stainless ashtray is the best mid-range compromise.
Choose based on how you use the ashtray: casual indoor smokers should prioritize compact, easy-to-clean models; outdoor users need lids and wind protection; cigar smokers should opt for wide rests and larger capacity. Our conclusions reflect hands-on performance, user feedback, and careful consideration of materials and design.