Choosing the right outdoor fireplace transforms your backyard, patio, or campsite from functional to memorable. Whether you want a portable smokeless pit for camping, a classic chiminea for cozy evenings, a propane fire table for entertaining, or a built-in statement piece, picking the correct style, size, and fuel type matters. The recommendations below come from comparative research, hands-on testing of representative units, and a review of expert and verified consumer feedback.
Considerations and Methodology
We evaluated candidates across real-world usage, expert testing notes, and consumer feedback with an eye on safety, build quality, ease of use/maintenance, and value. Key factors:
- Fuel type & heat output — wood, propane, or electric determines convenience, ambiance, and regulations.
- Build materials & durability — stainless steel, powder-coated steel, cast iron, or concrete affects longevity and corrosion resistance.
- Smoke control & airflow — important for comfort and neighbor-friendly burns (smokeless designs scored highly).
- Portability & installation — weight, included stands/covers, and whether it’s freestanding or permanently installed.
- Cleanup & maintenance — removable ash pans, grates, and covers reduce friction on repeated use.
Each shortlist product was tested (or evaluated from hands-on reports) for ignition and flame control, cleanup, and overall user experience. We also validated manufacturer specs (materials, dimensions, BTU where applicable) and cross-checked long-term durability reports from verified buyers.
37" Chiminea Fireplace
A budget-friendly chiminea-style outdoor fireplace that balances looks with function. Steel construction, mesh spark screen, removable ash pan, and included poker make this an economical option for small patios and casual gatherings seeking authentic wood-fire ambiance.
The 37" chiminea-style outdoor fireplace is the best low-cost way to get a real wood fire experience without breaking the bank. Built from high-grade steel, it includes a mesh spark screen, removable ash pan, log storage and a poker—simple features that matter in everyday use. This unit is relatively light and compact compared with large masonry fireplaces, so it fits most patios and decks. Expect solid performance for small groups; the chimney does a reasonable job directing smoke upward but won’t eliminate smoke entirely under all wind conditions. Assembly is straightforward and the included cover and ash pan simplify upkeep. Pros: attractive tower design, built-in log storage, easy cleanup. Cons: steel finish can show wear over time; not smokeless and less heat output than larger pits.
42" Propane Fire Table
A modern 42-inch propane fire pit table with 50,000 BTU output, RGB LED base lighting, tempered glass wind guard, and a convertible lid—ideal for entertaining and multi-use patios where clean, adjustable heat and ambiance are priorities.
If you want clean-burning, controllable heat and a multifunctional outdoor surface, this 42" propane fire pit table offers a compelling package. The central stainless-steel burner delivers up to 50,000 BTU from a standard 20 lb propane tank (regulator and hose included), producing reliable warmth for small groups. The unit converts to a coffee table with the included lid and adds RGB LED accent lighting to set mood and extend evening use. A tempered glass wind guard increases flame stability and safety in breezy conditions. Installation is mostly plug-and-play — no masonry or permanent installation required — and the integrated tank storage keeps the profile tidy. Downsides: requires propane refills and a flat stable surface; long-term weather exposure will still call for the included cover. Overall, strong versatility and performance at a mid-range price point.
Solo Stove Bonfire
A premium smokeless stainless-steel fire pit designed for portability and a clean burn. Advanced dual-airflow design, removable ash pan, stand, lid, and carrying case make it great for backyard evenings or on-the-go campfire gatherings.
The Solo Stove Bonfire is a standout for anyone who values a nearly smokeless, efficient wood burn in a portable package. Constructed from 304 stainless steel with a high-heat ceramic coating, its engineered double-wall airflow creates a secondary combustion that reduces smoke and increases heat efficiency. The included base plate, removable ash pan, stand, lid, shelter, and carrying case make this bundle exceptionally user-friendly for camping, tailgating, or residential patios. Cleanup is easier than with open pits thanks to the ash pan, and the relatively light weight (about 34 lbs for this model) improves portability. Drawbacks: as a premium product it costs more than basic chimineas, and while smokeless under many conditions, performance is influenced by fuel dryness and wind. Overall, this unit merges modern combustion engineering with practical accessories — that’s why it earns editor-level recommendation.
American Fyre Contractor
A built-in contractor-grade outdoor fireplace designed for large-scale installations. Monumental dimensions, concrete finish, and customizable integration make it the clear choice for permanent backyard focal points and commercial applications.
For homeowners and designers building a permanent outdoor hearth, the American Fyre Designs Contractor model is a top-tier option. This vented outdoor fireplace is constructed for large installations (notable dimensions and heavy materials) and is sold as a professional-grade, made-in-USA unit intended for contractors—ideal for custom patios, commercial terraces, and luxury landscapes. The concrete finish provides a durable, architectural look that integrates with masonry or contemporary settings, and its scale creates a commanding focal point with year-round usability. Downsides: price and required professional installation put it out of reach for casual buyers; it’s heavy and permanent by design. If you’re planning an invested, long-term outdoor renovation, this model offers unmatched presence and longevity.
Comparison Overview
Below is a concise comparison to help you match the right fireplace to your needs:
- 37" Chiminea Fireplace (Best Budget Pick) — Steel chiminea, removable ash pan, spark screen, log storage. Best for small patios and buyers on a tight budget.
- 42" Propane Fire Table (Best Value for Money) — 50,000 BTU gas burner, RGB LEDs, lid converts to table. Best for entertaining, clean heat, and multifunctional use.
- Solo Stove Bonfire (Editors Choice) — 304 stainless, dual-airflow smokeless design, highly portable with accessories. Best for low-smoke wood fires, campers, and backyard users wanting a premium portable pit.
- American Fyre Contractor (Premium Choice) — Large-format, contractor-grade concrete fireplace for permanent installs. Best for custom builds and luxury outdoor living spaces.
Best overall: The Solo Stove Bonfire strikes the best balance between performance, portability, and user experience for most buyers who want a reliable wood fire without persistent smoke.
Alternatives by need:
- Want minimal installation and controllable heat? Choose the propane fire table.
- On a tight budget but still want a wood fire focal point? The chiminea delivers value.
- Building a permanent, large-scale patio? The American Fyre contractor model is the clear premium choice.
Final Recommendation
Our review combined hands-on testing notes, product specifications, and consumer feedback to identify top outdoor fireplace options across different use cases. If you want the most versatile, low-smoke wood-fire experience with strong usability out of the box, the Solo Stove Bonfire is our top pick. For entertaining and a cleaner, controllable heat source, the 42" propane fire table offers the best value. Budget-conscious buyers who still want a classic wood-fire look should consider the 37" chiminea. And for permanent, high-end outdoor living spaces, the American Fyre Designs contractor unit provides unmatched scale and presence.
Choose based on where and how you plan to use the fireplace: portability and smokeless performance (Solo Stove), multifunction entertaining (propane table), low cost and classic aesthetic (chiminea), or long-term installed statement (American Fyre). Our selections are grounded in comparative testing, manufacturer specifications, and real-world user feedback to help you make a confident purchase.