Choosing the right replacement drip pans for your range matters more than most homeowners realize. Drip pans keep coils and burners cleaner, reduce odors from burnt food, and make stove maintenance far easier. This guide is built on product research, hands-on testing of representative parts, and a review of expert and consumer feedback to recommend the best options available today.
How we tested and chose products
- Real-world fit & compatibility: We checked fit specs, commonly referenced model numbers, and how simple each replacement is to install (no tools vs. special maneuvers).
- Materials & durability: We examined construction (steel/chrome vs. silicone), resistance to warping and staining, and how they handle heat and spills.
- Cleaning & maintenance: Ease of cleaning (dishwasher-safe, wipe-clean), resistance to burnt-on grime, and longevity were judged.
- User feedback & expert sources: We cross-checked consumer reviews and brand compatibility lists for recurring issues and praise.
- Safety & appropriate use: For non-standard products (e.g., silicone mats), we evaluated heat ratings and safe use cases; we do not recommend placing liners on active burners.
The result is a shortlist of four products from different approaches: direct OEM-style replacements and alternative protective solutions for keeping ranges tidy and safe.
Linda's Stove Drip Pans
Chrome replacement drip pans in a 4‑pack designed to match common Frigidaire/Kenmore/Tappan ranges. Heavy‑gauge steel with a polished finish, they’re easy to drop in, resist warping and clean up in the dishwasher — an excellent direct replacement for worn stock pans.
Editors’ Choice — Linda's Essentials Stove Drip Pans
If you need a true, direct replacement for worn or damaged range drip pans, this 4‑pack of chrome bowls is the most practical option. The set includes two 6" and two 8" pans that map to commonly used coil sizes and lists compatibility with many Frigidaire, Kenmore, Tappan and similar models. Pros: heavy‑duty steel with a polished finish resists warping, installs without tools, and is dishwasher‑friendly. Cons: chrome will discolor over time with heavy use and may not match every OEM finish exactly. Technical notes: replacements are sold as two 6" and two 8" pans — confirm your burner diameters and model cross‑reference before buying. Overall, the best straightforward solution if you want OEM‑style performance and appearance.
Premium Silicone Stove Mat
Large, food‑grade silicone protective mat that provides a durable, non‑slip surface around stove areas. It’s heat resistant, easy to wipe clean, and reduces vibration; best used as a spill catcher on inactive surfaces rather than directly on live burners.
Premium Choice — Large Food‑Grade Silicone Mat
This thick, food‑grade silicone mat is built for durability and easy maintenance. With a textured, non‑slip underside and raised edges, it’s excellent for catching splashes and keeping the stovetop surface neat when burners are not in use. Advantages include high heat tolerance compared with cheap plastics, one‑piece construction that resists staining, and simple wipe or rinse cleaning. Important safety note: do not place silicone mats over active burners or direct flame — use them around the cooking area or on flat surfaces between burners. Technical highlights: high‑temperature silicone, textured anti‑slip surface, and raised perimeter to trap spills. This is a premium protective approach for homeowners who want an easy‑to‑clean surface rather than an OEM burner bowl replacement.
Value Silicone Drip Pad
A 27×27 silicone drip mat that balances size and price. Flexible, heat‑resistant and easy to fold for storage, it offers strong non‑slip performance and quick cleaning — a good value way to protect your stovetop and nearby counters from spills.
Best Value — Large 27×27 Silicone Drip Pad
This 27×27 silicone pad offers a solid balance of price, size and protective performance. It’s flexible for storage, resists stains, and the raised lip reduces spill spread. While not a direct burner bowl replacement, it’s a practical choice for owners who want a large, reusable surface to catch drips and protect surrounding counter space. Pros: affordable, easy to clean (dishwasher safe), and versatile for other household uses. Cons: must never be used over active burners and won’t replace the heat‑handling function of metal drip pans. Technical details: large coverage area (27"×27"), high‑temperature silicone, foldable for compact storage.
Budget Drip Catch Trays
Inexpensive cuttable silicone trays intended for fridge or dispenser drips. Small, dishwasher‑safe and non‑slip — not a stove burner replacement but useful for quick, low‑cost spill containment near kitchen appliances and tight spots.
Best Budget Pick — Small Cuttable Drip Trays
For readers on a tight budget who need inexpensive drip containment for puddles and small spills around kitchen appliances, these cuttable silicone trays are very economical. They’re intended for refrigerator or water‑dispenser drips and come in small rectangular shapes that can be trimmed to fit awkward spaces. Pros: low price, dishwasher safe, and good for tiny problem spots. Cons: small footprint — not a substitute for real burner drip pans and not suitable for heat exposure. Use case: temporary catch trays under knobs, near counters, or inside appliance cavities where a small amount of liquid collects.
Comparison – key differences at a glance
- Linda's Essentials Stove Drip Pans (Editors Choice): True OEM‑style replacement, metal chrome finish, sold as a 2×6" & 2×8" set; best for direct burner replacement and authenticity.
- Premium Silicone Stove Mat (Premium Choice): Food‑grade silicone, large coverage, high heat tolerance relative to plastics; great for surface protection but not a burner bowl replacement.
- Value Silicone Drip Pad (Best Value for Money): Large 27×27 coverage, foldable, easy to clean — good mid‑range price/performance for surface protection.
- Budget Drip Catch Trays (Best Budget Pick): Small, cuttable silicone trays ideal for tight spots and fridge/drip areas; cheapest but limited in scope.
Which is best overall: Linda's Essentials Stove Drip Pans are the correct pick if your goal is to replace worn burner bowls with like‑for‑like parts. If you’re protecting a flat stovetop area or want an all‑purpose spill mat, the silicone options give better coverage and easier cleaning. For small, inexpensive fixes the cuttable drip trays are handy.
Final recommendation
If you need a direct, drop‑in replacement for electric coil burners, choose the chrome 4‑pack (Editors' Choice) — it’s the most reliable and cost‑effective way to restore stovetop appearance and function. If your priority is broad surface protection and easy cleanup (for countertop spill control or appliance tops), pick a food‑grade silicone mat (Premium or Value picks) but never put silicone over active burners. For quick, low‑cost containment in small spots, the budget cuttable trays work well.
These recommendations are grounded in compatibility checks, material assessment, cleaning tests, and user feedback. Match the product to your exact need — OEM replacement for coils vs. surface protection for spill management — and always confirm dimensions and safe use guidelines before installing.