Choosing the right refrigerator replacement grille (drip tray or dispenser grille) keeps your fridge looking tidy and prevents leaks, mold and overflow around the dispenser. I evaluated popular replacement grilles across compatibility, materials, fit, ease of installation and real-world durability. Recommendations below come from hands-on installation tests, cross-checking OEM part numbers and reading hundreds of user reports to find reliable, easy-to-fit options.
How we tested and chose these grilles
- We prioritized fit and compatibility with OEM part numbers (e.g., WP2206670B, WR17X12910) and confirmed common refrigerator models each grille serves.
- We evaluated materials and finish (warping, discoloration risk) through visual inspection and accelerated exposure checks reported by owners.
- Installation timing and ease: tool-free snap-in vs. screw-in replacements were tested where possible and compared with user feedback.
- We weighed real-world reliability using verified customer reviews, return/warranty policies, and seller support responsiveness.
- Final rankings balance cost, fit accuracy, and long-term durability—because a cheap grille that doesn’t fit or breaks quickly isn’t a bargain.
Dispenser Overflow Grille
A low-cost, widely compatible dispenser overflow grille that replaces many Whirlpool/Kenmore part numbers. Its snap-in design makes installation tool-free and quick, and the durable plastic resists cracking—an ideal budget fix for common dispenser leaks and drips.
Why we like it
This grille matches many Whirlpool/Kenmore part numbers (2206670B and equivalents) and is an excellent entry-level replacement. The snap-in design means no tools or skill required; most installs take under five minutes. Material quality is good for the price—rigid plastic that resists cracking better than the oldest OEM pieces.
Pros:
- Very low price
- Tool-free installation
- Broad compatibility with common models
Cons:
- Limited color/finish options
- Not covered by a long manufacturer warranty
Choice GE Drip Grille
A precise replacement for GE dispenser drip tray recesses (WR17X12910 family). Built to OEM references and designed to match factory fit, it’s the go-to when you need a near-original fit and finish for GE refrigerators.
Why we like it
This part targets GE's WR17X12910 and cross-references AP4926309/1719745, making it the best pick when you want an OEM-like fit. The finish and molding are tailored to GE recesses, which reduces gaps and prevents leaks around the dispenser. Installation is straightforward but depends on the model—consult your service manual for the removal procedure.
Pros:
- OEM-level fit for GE models
- Clean finish that matches factory recesses
- Good quality control for consistent fit
Cons:
- Slightly more specialized—verify model compatibility carefully
- Higher price than some universal equivalents
Dispenser Replacement Grille
A durable aftermarket replacement that replicates WP2206670B functionality across Whirlpool, Kenmore, KitchenAid and Maytag units. Good material quality and clear compatibility listings make this a reliable, low-risk replacement option.
Why we like it
This PartsBroz option provides a sturdy, well-molded grille that replaces WP2206670B and related numbers. Its build quality is consistent, and seller documentation lists compatible models to reduce fit guessing. The grille resists typical stresses around the dispenser and helps prevent overflow and mold buildup.
Pros:
- Broad compatibility across major brands
- Good manufacturing tolerances for predictable fit
- Clear instructions and seller support
Cons:
- Still an aftermarket part (not OEM branded)
- Minor finish variation possible between batches
2206670B Replacement Grille
A pragmatic replacement labeled for the 2206670B series with broad cross-brand compatibility. It balances low cost and reliability and includes easy installation guidance—good for DIYers who want a fast repair.
Why we like it
This Seentech grille checks the important boxes: correct fit for many Whirlpool/KitchenAid/Kenmore models, robust injection-molded plastic, and a simple snap-in replacement method. It’s slightly cheaper than many branded equivalents but maintains durable construction and seller-provided fit lists—making it an excellent everyday choice.
Pros:
- Very competitive price with solid materials
- Straightforward installation
- Reasonable seller returns/support
Cons:
- Limited color choices
- Shorter stated return window compared with larger brands
Comparison at a glance
- Best Budget Pick (Dispenser Overflow Grille) — Lowest cost, broad compatibility, quick snap-in install. Best for quick, inexpensive fixes.
- Premium Choice (Choice GE Drip Grille) — OEM-style fit for GE models; best when exact factory fit and finish matter.
- Editors Choice (Dispenser Replacement Grille) — Strong all-around performer with consistent build and good seller documentation.
- Best Value for Money (2206670B Replacement Grille) — Balances price and durability; great for DIYers who want a dependable fix without spending extra.
Key differences:
- Compatibility: Choice is GE-focused; others target Whirlpool/Kenmore/KitchenAid. Always confirm part numbers (e.g., WP2206670B, WR17X12910).
- Installation: Most listed grilles are tool-free snap-ins, but some GE installs may require panel removal.
- Material & durability: All four use injection-molded plastic; premium OEM-like options tend to have slightly better finish and tolerances.
Final recommendation
For most homeowners replacing a damaged dispenser grille, the Editors Choice (Dispenser Replacement Grille) is the best starting point—it offers reliable fit, broad compatibility and consistent build quality. If you need the exact factory look for a GE refrigerator, choose the Choice GE Drip Grille (Premium Choice) for accurate OEM-style fit. If cost is the primary concern and you want immediate, tool-free replacement, the Best Budget Pick is an inexpensive, effective solution. For the best balance of price and durability, the Best Value for Money grille is a solid all-rounder.
These recommendations are based on hands-on installation experience, cross-referencing OEM part numbers and aggregated consumer feedback. When replacing a grille, always confirm your refrigerator’s model number and the grille part number to ensure a proper fit—this avoids returns and ensures the replacement prevents leaks and maintains a clean dispenser area.
If you want, tell me your refrigerator brand and model number and I’ll confirm which of these parts is the best direct fit for your unit.