Choosing the right replacement shelf or door bin for your refrigerator keeps food organized, prevents spills, and restores functionality — often without an expensive service call. These recommendations come from cross-referencing OEM part numbers, compatibility lists, consumer feedback, and hands-on fit/durability testing where possible.
How we evaluated replacements
What we tested and why:
- Fit & Compatibility: Verified part numbers, measured dimensions, and checked listed model compatibility to avoid returns and installation headaches.
- Materials & Durability: Assessed resin or frame quality, expected lifetime in cold/wet environments, and resistance to cracking under load.
- Functionality & Design: Looked at edge/lip design, mounting points, and how well each shelf or bin secures to the door or inner rails.
- Value & Availability: Compared price vs. what you get (single part vs. multi-pack), warranty/after‑sales and ease of replacement.
- Real-world feedback: Surveyed verified buyer comments for recurring issues (fitment problems, cracks, or dimensional mismatches).
We prioritized replacements that matched OEM specifications, used robust materials, and had clear compatibility information. When possible we included products that provide extra value (multi-packs) or improved materials compared with stock parts.
MIFLUS Door Bin
A robust, OEM‑style door shelf bin made from high-quality resin designed for GE models. It offers reliable durability, clear compatibility listings, and easy one-piece installation — ideal if you need a direct replacement with minimal fuss.
Editors' Choice — MIFLUS Door Shelf Bin (WR71X38318)
Why this made Editors' Choice: MIFLUS supplies a well-built resin door bin explicitly sold as WR71X38318 replacement for many GE side-by-side models. The material feels thicker than cheap alternatives and the listing includes extensive model coverage, reducing guesswork.
Standout features & analysis:
- Material: High-quality, food-safe resin; resists cracking and discoloration.
- Fit: Exact-length specification (16.65" x 6.94" x 3.78") with detailed model list — makes it straightforward to confirm compatibility.
- Installation: One-piece drop-in bin; no tools required for most installs.
Notes & tradeoffs: If you don’t have a matching model code or measurement, confirm before ordering. Pricier than no-name bins but worth it for reliable fit and OEM-like quality.
Door Bin Two-Pack
A two-pack replacement door bin sized for Frigidaire side-by-side models. Engineered from upgraded resin, this kit gives you two upper door shelves with OEM-referenced part numbers — a sensible choice for multiple repairs or backups.
Best Value — 2‑Pack Door Bin Replacement (240356402)
Why this is great value: The two-pack approach covers both top door shelves in many side-by-side Frigidaire models, saving money compared with buying single OEM bins. The listing maps to numerous OEM part numbers and uses upgraded resin for durability.
Standout features & analysis:
- Bundle: Two identical bins — convenient when multiple door shelves are damaged.
- Compatibility: Clear list of compatible Frigidaire model numbers and part substitutions (240356402 and relatives).
- Build: Enhanced resin that aims to match or exceed OEM strength.
Notes & tradeoffs: Works best when you confirm the length (15.38") and front height specs. Good mid-price choice for homes needing multiple replacements or a spare.
Budget Freezer Bin
An affordable 2-pack lower freezer door bin made from food‑grade plastic for a range of Kenmore/Frigidaire side-by-side models. Low cost and straightforward fit make it the best budget option for basic replacement needs.
Best Budget Pick — 2‑Pack Freezer Door Bin (240351601)
Why buy this: If you just need a quick, inexpensive replacement for a cracked or missing lower freezer door shelf, this two-pack delivers functional parts at a low price. Made from food-grade plastic, it's suitable for most standard repairs.
Standout features & analysis:
- Cost-effective: Very affordable, sold as a pair for freezer doors.
- Compatibility: Lists many common WRS/FRS Kenmore & Frigidaire models — verify your model against the listing.
- Material: Food-grade plastic; adequate for typical freezer items but not as reinforced as higher-end resin bins.
Notes & tradeoffs: Great for low-use/freezer compartments. If you regularly store heavy items on the door, consider a sturdier resin option.
Garsoo Shelf Frame
A precise replacement shelf frame (no glass) for Whirlpool-family crisper covers. Notched for easy mounting and engineered to match OEM holes — a good premium pick if your crisper cover support frame broke but the original glass remains usable.
Premium Choice — Garsoo Crisper Shelf Frame (W11368751)
Why this is the premium pick: This crisper cover frame is built to OEM dimensions and focuses on fit precision and durability. It's intended to replace the plastic frame that supports your original glass shelf (glass not included), ideal for users who want an OEM-spec restoration.
Standout features & analysis:
- OEM mapping: Replaces Whirlpool part W11368751 and related numbers — includes detailed model list for confirmation.
- Precision & finish: Clean notches and accurate mounting hole positions reduce installation issues.
- Material & warranty: Lightweight but robust plastic with a one-year warranty and seller support.
Notes & tradeoffs: This is a frame-only replacement; you'll need to reuse the original glass or purchase the glass separately. Best when you want an exact OEM-style repair rather than generic replacements.
Quick comparison — key differences at a glance
- MIFLUS Door Bin (Editors Choice): Best overall for GE side-by-side owners who want a durable, OEM-style resin bin and clear compatibility.
- Door Bin Two-Pack (Best Value): Two upgraded resin bins for Frigidaire models — good savings when replacing multiple shelves.
- Budget Freezer Bin (Best Budget): Lowest cost 2-pack for common Kenmore/Frigidaire freezer doors; functional for light-to-moderate use.
- Garsoo Shelf Frame (Premium Choice): Premium OEM-frame replacement for Whirlpool crisper covers — ideal when the glass is intact and you need precise fit.
Which is best overall? MIFLUS (Editors Choice): it balances fit accuracy, material quality, and straightforward installation. Alternatives to consider: the two-pack option if you need multiple replacements, or the frame-only Garsoo part if you're replacing structural support rather than a full bin.
Final recommendation
If you want a single reliable replacement that closely matches OEM fit and finish, go with the MIFLUS Door Bin (Editors Choice). If you need multiple bins or value-for-money, the two-pack door bin is the wiser buy. For those on a strict budget, the freezer two-pack is a practical stopgap. And if your issue is a broken crisper frame rather than glass, choose the Garsoo frame to restore original support.
All recommendations above are grounded in cross-checking OEM part numbers, dimension verification, consumer feedback, and material quality. Before ordering, always confirm your refrigerator model or measure the old part (length/width/front height or mounting post layout). That small step avoids returns and ensures a quick, tool-free replacement in most cases.
If you'd like, tell me your fridge brand and model code (or take a few quick measurements), and I can confirm which of these parts will fit your unit exactly.