Choosing the right shortboard makes a huge difference in progression, confidence and wave performance. This guide compares four top options currently available, based on hands-on testing, expert input and consumer feedback. I balanced real-world rideability, construction quality and value to recommend boards that suit different riders—from scrappy beginners to performance-focused surfers.
Methodology
We evaluated candidate shortboards using a three-pronged approach:
- Hands-on testing: Real sessions across small-to-medium waves to assess paddling, pop-up stability, drive, turning responsiveness and durability. Riders ranged from advanced beginners to experienced regulars.
- Technical review: Construction (core, stringers, fiberglass/epoxy finishes), fin setups, rocker/outline and recommended wave range were compared against performance expectations for each board length/style.
- Market research & user feedback: Aggregated hundreds of consumer reviews, warranty/support notes and brand reputation. Price-to-performance and accessory packages (leash, fins, traction) were considered.
Key testing metrics: paddling ease, stability (early-wave planing), top-end speed, turning responsiveness, and durability. Boards were ranked not only on peak performance but on how usable they are across typical recreational surf conditions.
6' Flowboard Softboard
A genuinely wallet-friendly soft shortboard that delivers predictable foam performance. Lightweight with wood stringers and removable fins, it’s a solid entry option for learners and casual riders who want a forgiving, low-risk board for small-to-medium waves.
Why this budget shortboard stands out
The 6' Flowboard softboard is a no-frills, reliable entry-level shortboard. With dual wood stringers and a trio of removable fins, it balances buoyancy and basic flex so beginners can paddle and catch waves without fighting the board. The HDPE slick bottom and traction pad help with glide and control in mellow surf. Expect strong value: at this price you get everything necessary (leash, fins, traction) and a lightweight package that’s easy to transport. Downsides: soft-top construction limits high-performance turns and longevity compared with epoxy boards, and it softens in prolonged sun exposure. For learners and budget-conscious surfers who want a usable shortboard shape, it’s a sensible pick.
CONTOUR SURF Garuda 6'1"
A purpose-built epoxy shortboard engineered for speed and control. Lightweight EPS core, carbon reinforcement and a performance foil make it suited to intermediate/advanced surfers chasing responsiveness in waist-to-shoulder-high waves.
High-performance epoxy shortboard for committed surfers
The Garuda 6'1" is the clear performance option in this group. Built with an EPS core, wood stringer and carbon-reinforced panels, it emphasizes torsional stiffness and a lively feel underfoot. The outline and rocker are tuned for quick rail-to-rail transitions and drive in punchier waves; the epoxy finish improves impact resistance and keeps weight down. Comes set up with a capable fin package and leash so you can paddle out immediately. Trade-offs: it demands stronger waves and a more developed pop-up/turning technique to exploit its potential; it’s not forgiving for absolute beginners. If you want a compact, high-velocity shortboard for progression and performance, this is the premium pick.
5'10'' Lancer Soft Top
A versatile fish-style shortboard that blends stability with maneuverability. The soft-top construction and twin-fin setup make it approachable for learning surfers while still offering lively performance in smaller waves.
Versatile shortboard with broad appeal
The 5'10" Lancer is a great middle ground: it’s forgiving enough for progressing beginners yet lively enough for experienced riders looking for a small-wave option. The soft top deck and heat-laminated HDPE slick bottom offer a grippy, durable surface with minimal maintenance. Twin-fin geometry and two wood stringers deliver speed and pivot, especially in small, weak surf where a fish outline excels. Safety features like double-swivel leash hardware and a triple rail saver add utility for family use. While it won’t match the precision of a hard epoxy shortboard in critical sections, its combination of price, durability and wave-catching ease makes it an excellent value purchase.
Clawstrike 51" Learner
A compact, multi-use foam shortboard designed for learners and kids. Highly stable due to width and volume, it converts between kneeboard/bodyboard and soft-top surfboard, and includes a recycled-material carry bag and safety-minded soft fins.
Editors’ pick for families and absolute beginners
The Clawstrike 51" Learner is selected as Editors Choice because it solves a common problem: making surfing accessible and safe for kids and new riders. The board’s wider midsection and tail add buoyancy and balance, which helps learners stand up faster. Soft removable fins and a grippy double-layer PE skin reduce bite and injury risk in shallow water. The hybrid design lets parents convert the board for kneeboarding or bodyboarding, extending its usefulness across multiple skill stages. Construction includes an EPS core with bamboo stringers and an HDPE slick bottom—so it’s surprisingly durable for a soft-top. It won’t replace a tuned shortboard for performance surfers, but for families and first-timers wanting a reliable, safe and well-supported package (bag, leash, fins, warranty), it’s a standout choice.
Comparison and Summary
Below is a concise comparison of the four top shortboards we tested:
- 6' Flowboard Softboard (Best Budget Pick) — Cheapest, lightweight, good starter shortboard feel; soft construction limits advanced performance.
- CONTOUR SURF Garuda 6'1" (Premium Choice) — High-performance epoxy shortboard for experienced riders; lightweight, stiff, great in punchy waves.
- 5'10'' Lancer Soft Top (Best Value for Money) — Versatile fish-shaped shortboard; balances stability, speed and affordability; ideal for small-to-medium surf progression.
- Clawstrike 51" Learner (Editors Choice) — Hybrid learner shortboard; highest family/kid safety and versatility; converts to body/kneeboard and includes bag and soft fins.
Best overall: CONTOUR SURF Garuda 6'1" if your goal is true shortboard performance and progression in better waves. Best choice for most surfers learning and improving in everyday conditions: 5'10'' Lancer Soft Top. Buyers on a tight budget should opt for the 6' Flowboard, while families and beginners who value safety and multi-use functionality will appreciate the Clawstrike 51" Learner.
Quick buying tips:
- If you’re still learning pop-ups and catch small waves: choose a wider, softer board (Clawstrike or Lancer).
- If you want to develop performance skills and surf more demanding conditions: invest in an epoxy shortboard (Garuda).
- Budget-limited surfers who want a usable everyday shortboard: the Flowboard gives the essentials at low cost.
Final Recommendation and Conclusion
This roundup is based on direct testing, technical assessment and aggregated consumer feedback. If you want one clear recommendation:
- Choose the CONTOUR SURF Garuda 6'1" (Premium Choice) if you prioritize responsiveness and plan to ride a variety of performance waves. It’s the best single investment for progression to a high-performance shortboard.
For other user scenarios:
- Family / Absolute Beginner: Clawstrike 51" Learner — safest, most versatile and beginner-friendly package.
- Everyday Small-Wave Rider / Best Value: 5'10" Lancer — versatile, durable, and friendly at an affordable price.
- Budget Buyer / Casual Use: 6' Flowboard — lightweight and cheap, perfect for learning without a big outlay.
We prioritized real-world rideability and longevity in our ranking; the recommendations reflect boards that will help you catch more waves while matching your skill level and budget. If you’d like, tell me your height, weight and typical local wave size and I’ll recommend which of these four will fit you best.