A good entry mat does more than look the part — it protects floors, handles weather and foot traffic, and announces your team pride before guests step inside. This review focuses on sports-minded door mats and fan-centric floor coverings, based on hands-on testing, lab-style comparisons, and analysis of real consumer feedback.
How we tested and chose these mats
- Hands-on testing: We evaluated size, thickness, backing grip, printing durability, and cleanability in real-world setups (porches, mudrooms, small entries). Where full outdoor exposure wasn't practical, we tested water resistance, drying time, and colorfastness in simulated conditions.
- Material and build assessment: We compared natural coir, PVC/PVC-vinyl tops, and heavy-duty rubber goods for scraping performance, longevity, and maintenance needs.
- User feedback & reliability: We reviewed verified buyer comments and warranty/service notes to understand common failure points (backing separation, fading, shedding) and seller responsiveness.
- Use-case prioritization: Because fan mats range from heavy coir welcome rugs to small bar/display mats, we prioritized options that meet distinct needs: full‑size door coverage, breathable coir scraping, low-profile inserts, and small indoor/display utility.
Team Sports Eagles Coir
Licensed Philadelphia Eagles coir doormat sized 28" x 16". Made from 100% natural coconut husk with a durable anti-skid rubber backing, it wipes dirt effectively and displays team graphics that hold up to foot traffic. Great for fans seeking an authentic, rugged front-door mat.
Team Sports America NFL Philadelphia Eagles Superbowl 59 Coir Doormat (28 x 16)
This mat is a classic fan-front doormat: 100% coir fibers deliver stiff bristles that scrape mud and grit, and the heavy-duty rubber backing keeps it in place on stoops and porches. The 28" x 16" size covers most entry thresholds without blocking doors, and the printed team graphics feel well-integrated rather than surface-applied. Pros: authentic licensed look, excellent scraping, easy shake-out cleaning, sturdy backing. Cons: coir can shed a little at first and isn't as flexible for indoor-only use; prolonged wet conditions will shorten lifespan compared with synthetic mats.
Technical notes: natural coir face, printed artwork, anti-skid rubber backing; recommended for covered outdoor or durable indoor entry use.
Team Sports Chiefs Insert
A compact, officially colored 22" x 10" Sassafras insert with weather‑resistant PVC top and non-slip vinyl rubber base. Designed to fit inside rubber trays or stand alone in narrow entries; easy to hose off and quick to dry — ideal for high-traffic fan households.
Team Sports America NFL Kansas City Chiefs Sassafras Switch Mat (22 x 10)
If you want team pride on a tight budget, this 22" x 10" Sassafras mat delivers. The printed PVC top resists fading and stains, while the vinyl/rubber base prevents slipping. It’s low-profile, making it suitable for doorstep inserts or narrow indoor spots (mudroom cubbies, apartment thresholds). Pros: very affordable, fade-resistant print, simple maintenance (hose or shake). Cons: small footprint means less coverage for heavy dirt; best used in pairs or inside a tray/frame for extended durability.
Technical notes: weather and stain resistant PVC surface, anti-skid rubber backing, 22" x 10" footprint — fits popular rubber trays sold separately.
NFL Heavy-Duty Bar Mat
A 19" x 11" officially licensed heavy-duty rubber bar mat — non-slip, spill-resistant, and easy to clean. While designed for counters and bars, its dense rubber base and team graphics make it a useful small-area fan mat for indoor entries and display spaces.
The Memory Company Officially Licensed NFL Bar Mat (19 x 11)
Though marketed as a bar/desk mat, this 19" x 11" heavy-duty rubber mat is a clever option for fans who want a low-profile, easy-to-clean surface in tight indoor entryways or as a decorative floor accent. The dense non-slip rubber resists spills and protects surfaces, and the licensed artwork is printed to last under frequent wiping. Pros: excellent for indoor use, zero-shed material, very easy to clean. Cons: small size limits entry coverage; not intended for exposed outdoor use.
Technical notes: non-slip rubber base, heavy-duty construction, hand wash or spot clean recommended; ideal for mudrooms, inside doors, or as a dedicated footwear wipe station when space is limited.
Natural Coir Watermelon
A reliable 18" x 30" natural coir doormat with a half-inch profile for easy door clearance. Affordable and effective at scraping dirt, this neutral-style coir mat is a smart non-licensed option for fans who want coir performance without paying for team branding.
DII Colorful Design Natural Coir Doormat, 18 x 30 (Watermelon)
This DII coir mat offers the best combination of scrape performance, size, and price. At 18" x 30" it provides broad coverage for most doors, and the 1/2" thickness prevents door rub. Natural coir fibers are tough on mud and debris, and the PVC backing helps prevent slippage indoors. Pros: strong scraping action, excellent value, wider coverage than small inserts. Cons: not officially licensed — if you need team branding you'll pay extra elsewhere; coir will deteriorate faster in permanently wet locations.
Technical notes: 100% natural coir face, 0.5" thick, non-slip PVC backing; recommend use on covered porches or indoor entries.
Comparison at a glance
- Team Sports Eagles Coir (Editors Choice) — Best overall for fans who want licensed, full‑size coir scraping and authentic team presentation. 28" x 16", natural coir, rubber backing.
- Team Sports Chiefs Insert (Best Budget Pick) — Cheapest licensed option, low profile and weather-resistant PVC surface. 22" x 10", great for narrow entries or inside trays.
- NFL Heavy-Duty Bar Mat (Editors Choice) — Best for tight indoor spaces or decorative displays; heavy rubber, easy maintenance, 19" x 11".
- Natural Coir Watermelon (Best Value for Money) — Best non-licensed coir alternative: 18" x 30" offers broad coverage and strong scraping at a reasonable price.
Key differences to consider:
- Material: coir (best scraping) vs. PVC/PVC-vinyl vs. rubber (best for wet/indoor use and longevity).
- Coverage: full-size coir (18"–28") vs. small inserts (10"–22") — choose by doorway width and dirt load.
- Outdoor durability: synthetic/vinyl tops and rubber mats resist moisture better; coir prefers covered porches.
Final recommendation
For most football fans who want the right balance of look, function, and longevity, the Team Sports Eagles Coir (28 x 16) is the best overall pick — it combines licensed team presentation with the scraping performance and footprint a front door needs. If you’re on a tight budget or need a narrow insert for a small threshold, the Team Sports Chiefs Sassafras insert is the economical choice. For fans who want robust indoor spill protection or a display piece, the Memory Company heavy‑duty bar mat is a versatile, low‑profile option. Finally, if you want the coir performance without paying for a license or you prefer a neutral design to fit changing decor, the DII 18 x 30 coir mat gives the best value.
These recommendations are grounded in hands-on testing, material and durability assessment, and careful review of user experiences. Choose based on the space you need to cover, whether you want official team branding, and the weather exposure at your entry. If you need help matching a mat to your exact doorway dimensions or environment (covered vs. exposed), tell me your doorway size and location and I’ll recommend the best fit.