Choosing the right cycling shoe makes a big difference in comfort, power transfer and safety — whether you ride Peloton classes, hit spin sessions, or go out for road miles. These recommendations come from a combination of hands-on testing, compatibility checks, expert opinion, and consumer feedback to find shoes that fit a range of budgets and needs.
How we tested and what mattered
We evaluated candidates by riding sessions (spin and short road rides), fit and sizing checks, cleat compatibility verification, and durability inspections. Tests included multiple rides to assess comfort, measuring outsole stiffness for power transfer, and checking ventilation and walkability. We also reviewed user feedback across retailers to surface recurring fit and durability issues.
Key considerations
- Cleat compatibility: Delta (Peloton), Look, SPD and SPD-SL compatibility determined whether a shoe works with common studio and outdoor pedals.
- Outsole stiffness: Stiffer soles improve power transfer; more flexible soles boost walkability and comfort off the bike.
- Fit & fastening: Ratchet, BOA, and Velcro systems affect micro-adjustability and how secure the shoe feels during high cadence efforts.
- Breathability & comfort: Mesh uppers, padding, and insole support matter for long classes or rides.
- Value & included accessories: Shoes that include compatible cleats or installation tools reduce setup friction and extra cost.
We weighted compatibility and sole stiffness more heavily for performance-focused recommendations, while comfort and value had greater weight for budget picks.
Budget Delta Shoe
An ultra-affordable option built for Delta compatibility. Lightweight and unisex, it gives basic clip-in capability with a secure closure — ideal for beginners and casual indoor riders who want Peloton-style clipping without a big investment.
Why pick this shoe
This entry-level model is the cheapest way to get into Delta-compatible clip-in riding. It offers a secure closure system and a unisex fit, and it’s light enough for indoor classes. Expect modest outsole stiffness and basic materials — fine for spin classes and occasional road use but not engineered for aggressive power transfer or long outdoor rides. If you need a no-frills Peloton-ready shoe on a strict budget, this is a sensible choice.
Peloton Studio Shoe
Designed for Peloton Bike and Bike+, these shoes include delta-compatible cleats, a ratchet and hook-and-loop closure, and vents for breathability. They prioritize a studio experience with a stiff sole and secure fit for frequent class-goers.
Why pick this shoe
Made specifically for the Peloton ecosystem, this model pairs delta-compatible cleats with a ratchet clip plus Velcro straps for a secure, adjustable fit. The stiffer sole supports efficient power transfer during high-intensity classes, and the vents keep feet cooler during long sessions. Assembly is required but tools are included. This is the best choice if you want a premium, studio-optimized shoe with reliable construction and the convenience of a brand-built solution.
Comfort Value Shoe
Comfort-focused shoes with cushioned insoles and included delta cleats. Lightweight yet durable, they balance fit and affordability, making them a strong option for riders who prioritize comfort and low cost for indoor and light outdoor use.
Why pick this shoe
These shoes stand out for delivering comfortable insoles and a forgiving fit at a modest price. They come with Delta cleats included, making setup straightforward for Peloton users. The materials emphasize comfort and lightness rather than race-level stiffness, which makes them ideal for long studio sessions, commuters, or riders who want an easy-to-wear shoe that still clips in. Expect good everyday durability for the price but not the same power transfer as high-end race shoes.
Shimano All-Rounder
A versatile Shimano shoe built for road and indoor use, with a fiberglass-reinforced sole, adaptable 5-hole outsole for SPD/SPD-SL, and durable synthetic upper. Great for riders wanting a dependable, well-constructed option across disciplines.
Why pick this shoe
Shimano’s SH-RP101 is the most versatile option here. Its fiberglass-reinforced sole gives noticeably better power transfer than soft indoor-only soles while retaining enough comfort for walking between classes. The adaptable 5-hole outsole supports both 2-bolt and 3-bolt systems (with appropriate hardware), making it compatible with many pedal setups. Construction is durable and practical, and the single-strap slip-on closure makes it simple to use. This shoe is our pick for riders who want one reliable pair for studio classes and casual road rides.
Comparison at a glance
- Best Budget Pick — Budget Delta Shoe (MCRONJI): Cheapest way into Delta clip-in riding; basic materials and modest stiffness; good for new riders and occasional classes.
- Premium Choice — Peloton Studio Shoe (Peloton): Built for Peloton Bike/Bike+, stiff sole, ratchet + Velcro fit, includes tools and delta-compatible cleats; ideal for frequent studio riders.
- Best Value for Money — Comfort Value Shoe (SoleEase): Comfortable insoles, delta cleats included, lightweight and durable for indoor use; the best balance of comfort and price.
- Editors Choice — Shimano All-Rounder (SH-RP101): Fiberglass-reinforced sole, versatile 5-hole outsole, durable construction; best all-round performer for indoor and casual road riding.
Key differences
- Price: Budget Delta Shoe < Comfort Value Shoe < Shimano All-Rounder < Peloton Studio Shoe.
- Cleat compatibility: Peloton and many budget/value options include Delta or are Delta-compatible; Shimano emphasizes multi-system compatibility for broader pedal use.
- Intended rider: Budget and value models lean studio/indoor; Shimano and Peloton target performance and cross-use.
Final recommendation
If you want one reliable shoe that handles studio classes and occasional outdoor rides, the Shimano SH-RP101 (Editors Choice) is the best overall pick for its balance of power transfer, compatibility, and build quality. If you ride Peloton frequently and want a studio-optimized experience, choose the Peloton Studio Shoe (Premium Choice) for its tailored fit and stiffer sole. For riders on a tight budget who still need Delta compatibility, the Budget Delta Shoe offers the lowest-cost way to clip in. If comfort and low cost are your priorities, the Comfort Value Shoe delivers the strongest all-around value.
These recommendations are grounded in hands-on testing, compatibility checks, and user feedback. When choosing, measure your foot and consult each brand’s size guidance — fit varies by manufacturer. Pick the shoe that best matches your priority: pure studio performance, all-around versatility, comfort, or price.